if the offseason was now

Just bc Ceci has been better than Barrie doesn't mean he's been good... He has been barely over a replacement level player...

Firstly Ceci has not been better than Barrie, Barrie just hasn't been scoring points. That being said, he is far better than a replacement player. I think anyone who actually watches the Leafs this season would have to admit that while he isn't exceptional, he's been much better than what people on here have said he would be.

the tweet hes referencing shows some charts that say that Ceci>Barrie, and over his career, the only thing that made Ceci better than a replacement level player was his PIMs (or lack thereof) according to a different tweet by the same people that tweeted the Ceci>Barrie so far this year tweet

Why is Spezza resigned....or in the NHL next season. Doubt if DeSmith is the answer for the Leafs as a goalie and if he was, he cost more than an AHLer.
There ain't no way the Leafs can go with Ceci and Holl in the top six. A trade of cap heavy forwards is going to me necessary so cap can be spent on two NHL competent Dman. (Though I think both Ceci and Holl are OK), improvements are needed.

Barrie has been horrible defensively easily our worst Dman... including Marincin. Has not been good offensively and has been average with puck movement.