Are we still good if we swap these players

I don't understand the exercise. You mean lose all those players on waivers? Trade them?

But that line-up is far weaker than having those players (Nylander, Muzzin, and Holl especially) in.

How does the team look without these players, imagine they were just not on the team anymore

im bored and trying to see how many players the leafs could drop and still stay competitive

This is too many dropped players, probably looking like last years leafs

Also no depth with petan and lily as the next guys in then who the **** knows after that

Ah, I gotcha.

I think that team could compete in the league for a playoff spot. Definitely not legit contenders though. That lineup might be comparable to what the Oilers are now. Far more dependent on the top players to carry the team. Way less depth in the lineup.