Joined: May 2021
Posts: 15
Likes: 4
The Anaheim and Columbus trades are brutal from the Oilers' perspective. A top 10 drafted dman from 2019 (defence takes longer to develop such as Nurse), two high second-round picked forwards with promise that fell from the first round draft in their respective draft classes, and an additional first for a dman that plays similarly to Larsson and a third-line centre is a head-shaker for me. You even have Haula, a respectable and accountable 3rd-line centre, signed in FA. I like Manson, but Bob Murray's price is way too high. If we aren't acquiring Rakell (and signing an extension), Manson, and one of Comtois/Terry/Jones in exchange for your proposed package; the Oilers should steer clear.
Puljujarvi had an amazing defensive season while showing flashes of offensive confidence with his shooting decisions and zone entries, shipping him to Columbus for an ageing second-liner that has regressed the past two seasons while also giving a decent trade piece in Jones to Columbus does not make much sense either.
I like the Arvidsson trade, it's fair and he'd add that gritty forechecking ability needed to win offensive puck battles to help set up Mcdavid/Drai for their magic. For what the Oilers receiving in the Anaheim/Columbus trades; they can find replacement level players in free agency without giving up substantial assets.