Who adds what?
Joined: Jul. 2017
Posts: 13,677
Likes: 2,703
The top six were as good as Pittsburgh's top six, but the bottom six got smoked by a buncha quick little guys up from WBS.
Also, Connolly and Beagle were pointless. Beagle had a great playoff showing the year before, and might bounce back. Connolly is on a pace for a 20 goal regular season. Time to sell high, see if he'll bring back a decent playoff scoring threat to replace Williams.
Also, Shattenkirk was a 4th forward asked to play bottom pair with a physical, terriorial defensive specialist in Brooks Orpik. Shattenkirk is all offense and Orpik is all defense. They did not synergize. This is why it would be a mistake to trade for Mike Green at the deadline, unless it's part of moving out Carlson; Green on the third pair might not work with Orpik any better than Shattenkirk worked with Orpik. They're pretty similar players.
Lastly, Holtby had some weak games and just had to slog through. The Caps aren't a contender until they have a backup goalie their coaches trust to steal a game or two.