Quoting: Daryl
Interesting and possible idea. Tavares is for sure a better player than both Marner and Nylander. If we did sign JT we'd likely trade Marner considering Nylander already has a solid place on Matthews' wing. However, I don't see this happenin; blockbuster trades are a major risk, just look how trading Turris messed with Ottawa. Besides I'd hate to see Marner go, due to his incredible skill set, he's got great speed, hockey iq, stick handling, etc. So chances are if JT does hit FA, Lou will spare the locker room mess and just keep to the plan. On the other hand, this is a tough league in which only the best of the best can bring home the Cup, and signing Tavares would most certainly make Toronto among the best of the best, add in the stash of picks and prospects a Marner trade would acquire and you have a Cup winning team. Also factor in the fact that Tavares would likely be open to joining the Leafs in FA, and we have a super hard choice for Lou and management if JT goes unsigned.
Well, my thinking was Lou trades Marner for futures and rolls with Tavares. You could probably get (2) first round picks, (2) prospects and a roster player for Marner. If Lou did that the Leafs would have a stacked team and a cabinet stocked deep with prospects - it's kinda hard to argue against the idea of signing Tavares now eh? lol.. Of course there is always a risk there but at the end of the day it would basically be like trading Marner for Tavares, (2) firsts, (2) prospects and a #5 defenseman or bottom 6 forward.. Of course those picks and prospects could turn into nothing but if they do then that means the Leafs need new scouts or coaches but they still have Tavares... IMO the risk would be worth it... I'm obviously a Hawks fan so I'm looking at this situation objectively.....It certainly an interesting perspective..
The Leafs would be able to make one run at the Cup with Tavares, Matthews, Marner and Nylander tho.
IMO, the downside to this idea would be that there is a good chance that signing Tavares could create some locker room problems, and perhaps some resentment at Lou at the very least. Because if Lou signs Tavares someone knows they're gone after the season - that or someone is getting a lowball contract offer (Marner) lol so that could create some weirdness on the team..At the same time tho, hockey is a business and players should understand that... Also I wonder of Tavares would be OK taking a back seat to Matthews?
It will be interesting to see what Nylander gets tho......I'm shocked the Leafs haven't given him an extension yet..
My guess is at least $7,000,000 I mean he's more comparable to Draisaitl than he is a guy who makes $6,000,000 like RNH.
We will see soon enough.