Wow, when you look at it like that... EDM lost so many trades in that span. Was that all Chiarelli?

Most of those guys had bounce back years after those trades (obviously Hall, but also Petry, Dubnyk, Eberle, and Schultz).

Schultz would have never been a good player in Edmonton, they lack the coaching

This scenario was discussed here recently but the GReinhart trade with NYI in ‘16 for, in part, that year's 1-16 pick who became Barzal would most likely be a do-over as well.

IMHO Betterall would do the Caggiula trade. Five stars for that trade alone.
The Hall trade was rather bizarre, give the Eberle trade another year, and wait if Lucic can regain his form. Believe me he did a lot better than my GM disaster. Murray threw away a 2nd on Georges, two 2nd's and McNabb on two 4th line players, a 1st on Lehner, over paid to get Kane, infested the locker room with a cancer known as ROR, drafted poorly, and insulted the press & NHL. He took a last place team with a great future and turned it into a last place team with no future.