Quoting: mhockey91
Kessel and rantenen low.
Dubois and monahan low too.
JC and subban should both be 88.
It’s so tough to make these lists and you do like every day lmao I applaud you for that
Quoting: Capitalfail67
because in the last 2 years mcdavid has been way better? seems basic
points
190 (2nd) mcdavid 137gp
155 (10th) crosby 136 gp
goals
72 (2nd) mcdavid
53 (34th) crosby
I mean this is basic stats but seems like the 2 major offensive categories mcdavid is in the top 2 and crosby is in the top 10 in one and outside the top 30 in the other..
also mcdavid is on a way less talented team. honestly there so many things that would point to him being better..... now if they were both 21 crosby all day.
Quoting: pharrow
Crosby basically shuts McDavid down every time they play. He's 6-0 vs him. After that last game against each other, I don't know how any can honestly still argue this.
Something tells me Crosby holds that spot till he's 33-34. At which point he will probably be looking at retiring.
Pharrow its crazy to compare players by thier records against one another. If McDavid had Malkin, Letang, Kessel and Matt Murray as his teammates and Crosby was playing on a line with Ty Rattie it would be a whole different story. its pretty much a consesus among everyone who knows anything about hockey that 97 has an edge over 87 now. Its amazing McDavid is even able to put up points with the talent he has around him on such a dysfunctional franchise.
Sorry guys I know i post the rankings a lot just looking for feedback and trying to fine tune them as best I can. I guess i have this fantasy that I will post the rankings one day and every person will be in agreement and think its the perfect list which I know is impossible.
I get bored at work a lot and look at different advanced stats and make adjustments to the rankings based on recent performance and comments from other CapFriendly members when a good argument is made as to why a player should be higher or lower.
I will start posting less frequently if it is annoying to others and maybe start doing every month or couple weeks or something. Anyways thanks for the feedback guys I really appreciate it.