I could see Tkachuk holding out for a little more than that, he may want in the 9mil range to give up a full 8 years, but you're pretty close and nothing else is unrealistic so I give you 5/5

I feel if that's all we get for Brodie you fire Treliving.
I'd rather just keep him for one more year.

yeah i was gonna say,

I didn't watch a lot of CGY this year but he could not have fallen off that far

He might want 9milbut he won't get it. He might also be worth it but with Treliving's ability to negotiate he'll probably get 7.5 - 8 x 8 years with full NMC. After what happened with Nylander and how bad he played I don't think anybody every holds out again but who ones, maybe they do.

Benny and Ritter are a little low As much as I would like to see Chucky locked for 8, I think it'll be a bridge, 6 X 5 maybe and if we have to do a 5th with Brodie for a third then no problem, we keep Brodie

I honestly think if it’s 8 he wants, you strongly consider moving him