Banned
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 24,997
Likes: 7,855
2 things,
1) Islanders can't offer 8 years of term.
2) TO is likely to offer that exact contract to Marner and actually be able to include the 8th year
Offer sheets are stupid and just won't ever work.
Why? Good Question.
So lets say Dubas is sitting in his office and its the last week of June. Marner will be signed by then for sure, but lets say that Kapanen is still without a contract and he's wanting 4+ or something the Leafs just can't afford. What do you think Dubas would do?
Option A
Nothing, he just sits there for a week and then watches as someone gives Kapanen the contract he wants and he is gone for a 2nd rounder or something. (There is entirely a strong possibility that Kap's agent creates a bidding war for his client and gets a contract in the 5+ range and the Leafs get a 1st and 3rd but that is unlikely)
Option B
Dubas sees the writing on the wall and instead of doing nothing, he tells all the other GM's that Kapanen is available and starts fielding offers. There would be a dozen teams or so who would have interest and the best offer would win. Which would exceed anything that would come from an accepted offer sheet.