Quoting: EricRobson77
I think the thing that bugs me the most is do you think Marner is worth 2-3 million dollars MORE than Nikita Kucherov? I get Tampa has no sales tax which is why Kuch is lower than expected but still. I think if I was Dumbas 9.5 would be as high as I would want to go.
Quoting: DONTGIVEAPUCK13
Leafs have put them themselves in this position by signing tavares. Marner will not sign that contract, someone will have not problem sending him a 5yr $10.5 contract where compensation is only two 1st, 2nd and 3rd.
And what comparables are you using? 2009? Unfortunately for the leafs Marner is showing he is equal to Matthews so why does he just get paid 2.5 less per year?
It is weirdly not that much more with the sales tax. It not as significant. It is something, but not crazy.
And comparables, yes 2009- Kane he signed his 2nd deal at 11%. % of cap s hould be similar over the years. The trend and they have very similar point totals. Also, if you look at Brayden Point and Ratanen, you have "experts" who say Mitch is worth 11.5M saying Brayden and Ratanen are only worth 8.5ish. Meanwhile Ratanen had a better points, Brayden plays center and was 4 points shy of Marner. Doesnt really make much sense that Mitch is worth more.
Also, before this year, Mitch and Nylander were trending the same. Mitch had a great year, some credit is given to JT, there is proof he makes great players better. Also in a league where the objective is to score goals, Matthews is on another level compared to most if not all other people in the NHL at 5v5. He is also a center, a more valuable position.