Joined: Mar. 2019
Posts: 2,780
Likes: 2,624
I was never high on Gardiner but accepted that he was one of the better puck moving D the Leafs had. That said, after getting Barrie I really don't think Gardiner is a good D to bring back even at a discount.
Neither Barrie or Gardiner are known for good defensive play and this is why Gardiner is the guy you don't bring back, cause the Barrie trade suddenly being reversed.
The Leafs just need a steady 3rd pairing D, nothing flashy by any means. That could just mean finding a cheap option (McQuaid?) and toughing it out on 3rd pairing with Ceci/Borgman til Dermott is back.
Also trading Hyman is a mistake. Between now and when Hyman becomes a UFA, Dubas needs to find/develop some grit...and no, Timasov is not ready for a regular spot on the roster.