Getting something useful back for Frolik is good but you would be better off with a right handed winger or rhd prospect.

I like the deal and would be completely fine if it were to happen, if I were to nit pick, I would love to see a right shot forward come in to replace Frolik, minor detail but just my thoughts!

Who would you say is better at their best, Tkachuk or Marner?

Marner is more talented, who is more valuable to their team? I think Tkachuk, that's a lot tougher question though and you'll get varying answers on that. the initial question I think you'll be hard pressed to find too many guys saying Tkachuk

I agree with SmugTkachuk, Marner is Dangerous offensively, but Tkachuk is developing an all around game. with a 57% corsi for and a 46% off zone starts, combined with 77 point last season, i'd sasy thats pretty deadly. Marner has a corsi for of 51% and a 54% offensive zone starts, with 92 Points last season. Both VERY talented players in their own right.

Tkachuk is much closer to marner than most people give him credit for. Just in goals alone he leads. seems to be forgotten these days. The abrasive edge he gives is also a commodity. I still give the edge to marner but it is very close.