I think goalies like Bishop, Vasi, Price, Bobrovsky, Holtby are better
nah Gibson is a stud, without him the Ducks would have been worse than the Sens last year. When you take Age, Contract, ability all into consideration, 9 out of 10 peopel would take Gibson over those goalies you listed
He has to carry a team far or at least one that isn't favored to be a playoff team into the playoffs to be considered among those goalies imo
If that's the criteria, you should take Vasi out of the running full stop. You could put any goalie in the league on that team and at least make the playoffs. Gibson has better career numbers than Vasilevsky, and played on a much worse team.
Gibson in net has been the thing that has kept the Ducks from being in the basement these last few years.