Spurgeon is a great dman–and, if you're an analytics nerd, one of the best in the league. But this is not a good contract because of its length and his age.
Had Spurgeon been two years younger, or if this deal was for only five years, it'd be good. However, that is clearly not the case.
And giving him a TOP 10 NHL defenceman caphit is ridiculous.
It really is not ridiculous. Spurgeon is an incredible defensive defenseman while being offensively productive and driving play. How would you argue that he is not underrated?
It really is not ridiculous. Spurgeon is an incredible defensive defenseman while being offensively productive and driving play. How would you argue that he is not underrated?
There is nothing you can do to convince me that signing a 5'9 defense man till he's 36-37 years old is a smart decision.
Especially at 7.5 million.
Can anyone name me one defense man 35+ who is 5'9???????
I can't think of one.
Well he is not Hedman, Carlson or Trouba (When he will get to his prime) good. But he got the same money.
Cast your vote for him for the next Norris Trophy winner if you want, but you will be the only one and that won't be because he is underrated.
Sure, he's not Hedman, but he is certainly not worse than Carlson and he is much better than Trouba. He is regarded as a top ~10 defenseman in the analytics community FWIW.
I'm not saying Spurgeon is a top 3 defenseman, but this contract is fair for what he brings and the fact that so many people think it is a 'ridiculous' contract just speaks to how underrated he is.
Sure, he's not Hedman, but he is certainly not worse than Carlson and he is much better than Trouba. He is regarded as a top ~10 defenseman in the analytics community FWIW.
I'm not saying Spurgeon is a top 3 defenseman, but this contract is fair for what he brings and the fact that so many people think it is a 'ridiculous' contract just speaks to how underrated he is.
He's not anywhere close to the level of anyone around him in terms of AAV.
He's ideally a top 3 defensemen on a perfect team. Doesn't help that this contract starts around the time most defenders start toregress.
He's not anywhere close to the level of anyone around him in terms of AAV.
He's better than OEL, Ekblad, Trouba, Carlson, Byfuglien, probably Subban and Weber, too.
Quoting: HabsForEver
He's ideally a top 3 defensemen on a perfect team.
What's a perfect team? A team with the best six defensemen in the league?
Quoting: HabsForEver
Doesn't help that this contract starts around the time most defenders start toregress.
I sort of agree with this, there's definitely a chance that the AAV will be a bit high in the last two years or so, but then again, the cap will be higher.