Not worth it for edm..

Top for dman for edm plus a consistent 20 goal scoring winger in exchange for a player that won't play for them and a first round pick that will be outside of the top 10. If anything Edmonton gets a better deal than Chicago

I mean if the pick is outside the top 10 sure still not much confidence in Edm

Not worth it for the hawks in that edmonton trade. Pool Party isn't worth anything more then a 2nd rounder if that. Saad is worth a 1st rounder or a 2nd and 3rd and Murphy a 2nd rounder conservatively, why are the Hawks adding a 2nd round pick?

I would not pay Gus that kind of money, I think he should be traded by the deadline. We aren't going to need him when we have a similar player in Adam Boqvist

I think you way overvalue Saad

I think you way over value Pool Party. Saad is a better version of Ferland or similar to a Nyquist type of player...he's a million overpaid but that doesn't make him a bad player. Pool Party is an experiment.