Guentzel by a mile. I think Keller k
Has more skill, but he hasn't flipped the switch yet, and Guentzel has been a star.

Right now? JG.

Skill? Keller. Production? Guentzel.

Guentzel all day every day

Yeah for me, Guentzel is better right now but I think Keller has a higher ceiling. Although some might argue that Guentzel gets to play with Crosby.

flip the players and let keller play every night with Crosby and I wonder what we think

But the thing is, it's actually very difficult to play with Crosby. He's picky about the types of players on his wing and that's why he hasn't always had success with high profile talents like Kessel for example. Guentzel's hockey sense and ability to simplify the game has been the reason why he's found so much success.

well the fact that he fits so well with Crosby doesn't make him better it just stresses the point that a lot of his success is from syd. now would keller fit idk but give him an elite level player to skate next too and wed see. my gut says guentzel is better but keller has done well with less