Forums/Armchair-GM

Evgeni Malkin vs Auston Matthews

Created by: MikeyThePensFan
Initial Creation Date: Nov 7, 2019
Published: Nov 8 at 12:42 pm
Team: 2019-20 Pittsburgh Penguins
Team Explanation
During Auston Matthews' draft year, there were many experts who said he was a very similar type of player to Malkin. Big, dominant and more defensively responsible.

Now, the real question is, who is better?

I will only compare them based off their first 3 seasons since that is only fair; Matthews hasn't hit his prime whereas Malkin is past it.

So, Matthews has 205 points (111 goals) in 212 regular season games (0.96 PPG). In the playoffs, he has 10 goals and 13 points in 20 games (0.65 PPG).

Malkin in 242 regular season games scored 115 goals and 304 points (1.256 PPG). In the playoffs, he had 24 goals and 62 points in 49 games (1.26 PPG).

So, who's better?
Buried
  • Casey DeSmith: $175,000 ($1,250,000)
DRAFT YEARROUND 1ROUND 2ROUND 3ROUND 4ROUND 5ROUND 6ROUND 7
2020
PIT
PIT
PIT
PIT
PIT
2021
PIT
PIT
PIT
PIT
PIT
ANA
2022
PIT
PIT
PIT
PIT
PIT
PIT
PIT
ROSTER SIZESALARY CAPCAP HITOVERAGES BONUSESCAP SPACE
22$81,500,000$66,574,125$132,500$3,832,500$14,925,875
Left WingCenterRight Wing
PIT
Guentzel, Jake
$6,000,000
LW, RW
UFA - 5
PIT
Crosby, Sidney
$8,700,000
C
NMC
UFA - 6
PIT
Galchenyuk, Alex
$4,900,000
LW, C, RW
UFA - 1
PIT
McCann, Jared
$1,250,000
LW, C
RFA - 1
PIT
Malkin, Evgeni
$9,500,000
C
NMC
UFA - 3
PIT
Rust, Bryan
$3,500,000
RW, LW
UFA - 3
PIT
Kahun, Dominik
$925,000
LW, RW, C
RFA - 1
PIT
Bjugstad, Nick
$4,100,000
C, RW
UFA - 2
PIT
Simon, Dominik
$750,000
RW, LW
RFA - 1
PIT
Aston-Reese, Zach
$1,000,000
LW, RW
RFA - 2
PIT
Blueger, Teddy
$750,000
C, LW
RFA - 2
PIT
Tanev, Brandon
$3,500,000
RW, LW
NTC
UFA - 6
Left DefenseRight DefenseGoaltender
PIT
Dumoulin, Brian
$4,100,000
LD
UFA - 4
PIT
Marino, John
$925,000
D
RFA - 2
PIT
Murray, Matt
$3,750,000
G
RFA - 1
PIT
Pettersson, Marcus
$874,125
LD
RFA - 1
PIT
Schultz, Justin
$5,500,000
RD
NTC
UFA - 1
PIT
Jarry, Tristan
$675,000
G
RFA - 1
PIT
Johnson, Jack
$3,250,000
LD
UFA - 4
PIT
Ruhwedel, Chad
$700,000
RD
UFA - 2
ScratchesInjured Reserve (IR)Long Term IR (LTIR)
PIT
Riikola, Juuso
$850,000
D
RFA - 1
PIT
Hörnqvist, Patric
$5,300,000
RW
NTC
UFA - 4
PIT
Lafferty, Sam
$767,500
C, LW
RFA - 1
PIT
Letang, Kris
$7,250,000
RD
NMC NTC
UFA - 3

Embed Code

  • To display this team on another website or blog, add this iFrame to the appropriate page
  • Customize the height attribute in the iFrame code below to fit your website appropriately. Minimum recommended: 400px.

Text-Embed

Click to Highlight
Who is better?
The chart has been hidden

Poll Options

 

Nov 8 at 12:44
#1
RangerWall92
Joined: Nov 2018
Posts: 986
Likes: 158
Matthews is better
Nov 8 at 12:51
#2
Thread Starter
Mikey F.
Joined: Sep 2019
Posts: 821
Likes: 185
@Yojimbo @pharrow @sidstick87 Make sure you guys comment on this!
Nov 8 at 12:52
#3
bigZ
Joined: Jun 2019
Posts: 279
Likes: 114
Quoting: RangerWall92
Matthews is better


LMAO what di fook is dis. Malkin takes sh*ts better than Matthews
Nov 8 at 1:02
#4
Dr.
Joined: May 2019
Posts: 578
Likes: 158
You kind of forget how dominant Malkin was with Crosby getting all the attention
Nov 8 at 1:05
#5
Joined: Jul 2018
Posts: 657
Likes: 155
Malkin.... Malkin is one of the best players all time when hes on his game
mhockey91 and Pens3lieve liked this.
Nov 8 at 1:07
#6
Thread Starter
Mikey F.
Joined: Sep 2019
Posts: 821
Likes: 185
Quoting: RangerWall92
Matthews is better


Don't forget to vote!
Nov 8 at 1:10
#7
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 10,369
Likes: 3,070
The real question is who was a better goal scorer, Malkin or Joe Malone.

The second real question is, what is the point of this post? Pens fans looking to reminisce about when Malkin was arguably the 2nd best player in the game behind their other centre? Or is this just a weird attempt at riling up Leaf fans.
Nov 8 at 1:16
#8
Joined: Jun 2018
Posts: 7,330
Likes: 1,479
In the first 3 years only?
I think Malkin was the better player.
Look it's hard to judge this. The game has really changed. There is a huge emphasis on speed now, that wasn't the case when Malkin came into the league. Because of that, he looked so much more dominate that a lot of the other players in the league.
Mathews is going to have most of his career in a different era. It's a track meet out there now. There are better athletes out on the ice, and to be as dominate is a much harder task today than it was 10 years ago. There are also changes in things like goalie equipment and the rules to the game. All those things mess with numbers so I don't really think you can look simply at numbers and I don't think it's really easy to compare to their "peers" because of the qualitative difference there.

What I do know, is that Malkin was the best player on the ice when they won a cup in 09 in his 3rd year. And one could also make the argument he was the best player on the ice the year they lost in 08.
They did that in the salary cap era. With the same sort of challenges TOR has do deal with. And they did it against arguably a better team in Detroit.
Nov 8 at 1:31
#9
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 1,887
Likes: 698
Quoting: LoganOllivier
The real question is who was a better goal scorer, Malkin or Joe Malone.

The second real question is, what is the point of this post? Pens fans looking to reminisce about when Malkin was arguably the 2nd best player in the game behind their other centre? Or is this just a weird attempt at riling up Leaf fans.


Its not that deep
CBJ4CUP liked this.
Nov 8 at 1:38
#10
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 10,369
Likes: 3,070
Quoting: hockeyfanatic05
Its not that deep


But what of Joe Malone? Single greatest ever goal scoring season in the history of the league. Almost no one knows his name.
Nov 8 at 2:19
#11
TML1991
Joined: Feb 2016
Posts: 516
Likes: 112
Quoting: CBJ4CUP
Malkin.... Malkin is one of the best players all time when hes on his game


not even a top 100 player tho
CBJ4CUP liked this.
Nov 8 at 2:26
#12
Joined: Apr 2018
Posts: 2,902
Likes: 744
I am going to lean Malkin.

However, Malkin had the advantage of Crosby being on the other line pulling defensive assignments from both top D and top defensive forwards.
Nov 8 at 2:33
#13
Joined: Jul 2016
Posts: 3,504
Likes: 947
Right now? Matthew is better. But if we are comparing primes it's Malkin.
BurgerBoss liked this.
Nov 8 at 2:39
#14
Thread Starter
Mikey F.
Joined: Sep 2019
Posts: 821
Likes: 185
Quoting: hockeyfanatic05
Its not that deep


Quoting: LoganOllivier
But what of Joe Malone? Single greatest ever goal scoring season in the history of the league. Almost no one knows his name.


Everyone knows that Joe Malone was one of the pure goal scorers ever, but he is not the same type of player as Malkin. Malkin, Matthews and Byfield all play the same style, they're big, have tremendous skill and are dominant.
Nov 8 at 2:39
#15
Joined: Jul 2018
Posts: 657
Likes: 155
Quoting: TML1991
not even a top 100 player tho


This is true, fk
Nov 8 at 2:39
#16
Thread Starter
Mikey F.
Joined: Sep 2019
Posts: 821
Likes: 185
Quoting: ClockReads2113
Right now? Matthew is better. But if we are comparing primes it's Malkin.


Well, Matthews hasn't peaked yet, that's why I'm only comparing based off their first 3 seasons.
Nov 8 at 2:40
#17
Joined: Jul 2018
Posts: 657
Likes: 155
Quoting: MikeyThePensFan
Everyone knows that Joe Malone was one of the pure goal scorers ever, but he is not the same type of player as Malkin. Malkin, Matthews and Byfield all play the same style, they're big, have tremendous skill and are dominant.


Logan Oliver is a joke, literally knows nothen
Nov 8 at 2:41
#18
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 10,369
Likes: 3,070
Quoting: MikeyThePensFan
Everyone knows that Joe Malone was one of the pure goal scorers ever, but he is not the same type of player as Malkin. Malkin, Matthews and Byfield all play the same style, they're big, have tremendous skill and are dominant.


What are you talking about! Joe Malone scored more than 2 goals a game! His goals per game were higher than Malkins points per game! Why are we not talking more about Joe Malone?
Nov 8 at 2:41
#19
Burgers and Hockey
Joined: Oct 2017
Posts: 8,057
Likes: 3,399
Quoting: ClockReads2113
Right now? Matthew is better. But if we are comparing primes it's Malkin.


This.
Nov 8 at 2:42
#20
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 10,369
Likes: 3,070
Quoting: CBJ4CUP
Logan Oliver is a joke, literally knows nothen


Seriously? For being the guy that someone just said "Knows nothing" you are chirping Joe Malone without knowing who he is. Give him a quick google there boomer before throwing out insults. Joe Malone is sick.
Nov 8 at 3:00
#21
Joined: Jan 2017
Posts: 2,858
Likes: 657
Malkin. Not even a competition.
Pens3lieve liked this.
Nov 8 at 4:38
#22
Joined: Jul 2018
Posts: 657
Likes: 155
Quoting: LoganOllivier
Seriously? For being the guy that someone just said "Knows nothing" you are chirping Joe Malone without knowing who he is. Give him a quick google there boomer before throwing out insults. Joe Malone is sick.


Im not denying that, but you also said Nylander will be a 90 point guy?
Nov 8 at 4:42
#23
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 10,369
Likes: 3,070
Quoting: CBJ4CUP
Im not denying that, but you also said Nylander will be a 90 point guy?


Even Nylander can't hold a candle to Joe Malone!
Nov 8 at 6:00
#24
Joined: Jul 2018
Posts: 657
Likes: 155
Quoting: LoganOllivier
Even Nylander can't hold a candle to Joe Malone!


ahhh just waiting for the day for you swallow ur pride about nylander and marner contract situation
Nov 8 at 7:39
#25
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 10,369
Likes: 3,070
Quoting: CBJ4CUP
ahhh just waiting for the day for you swallow ur pride about nylander and marner contract situation


Imagine what Malone would make in this market!
 
Reply
To create a post please Login or Register
Question:
Options:
Submit Poll Edit