Quoting: BeterChiarelli
Did Vesalainen just fall off a cliff or what? That's the name I would think immediately comes in for Perreault unless he's more comfortable on his off wing.
I'd argue Russell's on par with Beaulieu in terms of talent (value it's not even close, Nathan by a mile) and would be an immediate upgrade over Sbisa, Poolman, and the aforementioned Bitetto.
"And player X would be performing bettwe if he wasn't glued to player Y". Blah, blah, blah. Perreault's production is what it is right now. The fantasy of him playing with any other player does not change the fact that he's on pace for 24 points as of today. I can recognize that Lowry is a sink on production, but that alone cannot dictate any player's value. In the past three years Perreault has trended from average second-line winger to average third line winger. Are you expecting to get a top-4 defender and a pick for him?
Best I'd do is drop the 6th heading to Edmonton and add a 5th Round Pick. Edmonton needs a new third line and the Jets need NHL-capable defencemen. The cap basically washes out, make this work.
Vesalainen is gonna need a full season in the AHL imo, he has yet to impress and is off to a slow start with the Moose. He's definitely not ready to replace anyone in the Jets top 9 wings yet and he's not a 4th line player.
I'm not sure Russell would be an improvement on Poolman but yeah he's likely an improvement on Sbisa though Sbisa has played alright so far, Kulikov is hit and miss but we're used to that.. Lol..Bitetto isn't good at all and Dahlstrom was great when he played imo so they have plenty of decent depth dmen plus Niku playing well with the Moose, they're not as weak on defense as its made out to be. So is it worth it to trade a good 3rd line winger who can be moved into the top 6 if necessary for a dman that you have similar of already? I'd say it's not.
People really don't grasp how starved for offense anyone who's stuck with Lowry is, shift Copp to the center and put almost anyone else on the other wing and Perreault is likely on a 30-35 point pace instead of 24 as you've mentioned, not a huge difference but pretty typical 3rd line production. Btw Lowry is on pace for 9 points, yes it's that bad.. Lol... And people can give me Lowry's good Corsi numbers/shutdown role blah blah blah but if you play as much as he does you have to produce better then that, period.
Gawd no I don't expect a top 4 D for Perreault.. Lol
Honestly I think a 4th round pick is the best they'd get for him and I like Russell and think the value is fair but I think that Perreault is still more valuable to the Jets then Russell would be. The Jets are very thin up front, they really can't afford to deal Perreault until the season is over, Appleton and Bourque are both out for another month probably and both are downgrades on Perreault, as it stands Maurice only plays his 4th line like 6-8 minutes a night plus Little's unfortunate injury makes keeping Perreault even more necessary.