I would say it is.

I would hope dubas tries to keep Lilly but at this point you have dumba and Holl and would only need a 3rd pair Dman for the next 3 years.

I am not really interested in Dumba, he seems to me like a guy who should be a top pair player but just can't put it together for extended periods. It would cost a tonne and I really like how Lilly is developing. I'd sooner keep him and find someone else.

Dumba’s numbers are down from previous years, so it may be opportune time to make the right offer to the Wild. I like the Leafs offered here. This is a balanced trade. However, a player like Dumba, 7th overall, with enormous upside practically demands a 1st to grab Guerin’s attention.

Minnesota seems to be spinning their wheels, another year looms as the club fails to make the post season. If the Wild are a playoff bubble team, then they will keep Dumba for their push, but if it is clear they are out by the end of February, that deal could happen.

Guerin has been patient, looking at his team weaknesses. I think if he does pull the trigger moving Dumba, it will most likely come in the off season.

I agree and add that Dumba's only real solid year was when his contract was comming up and there is the risk he is only motivated when he could make more money.

Liligren or a 1st would be the question in this trade.

Dumba is a player that teams have a chance to buy low on right now so would be interesting to see what he could fetch. Keep in mind though, he is more of a goal scoring dman, likes to shoot so I dont know if that would fit in with Toronto and all thier guys who like to pull the trigger.

Dumba is good, but if he's locked in for the next 3 years then Muzzin won't be re-signed. Yeah this makes your D look great for this year, but then you go into the offseason without Muzzin, Kapanan, Lilly, and a couple draft picks that you could have kept by just re-signing Muzzin.