Burns? I dont think so.

I would put cirelli on there

Cirel... Oh wait, I forgot PPP=elite defensively

Couture.

Wheres my boy Marner??? An elite Penalty Killer/playmaker

I agree with most of your forwards, but what is two-way about that defense? Other than Hedman and maybe Jones, none of those guys are very responsible defensively. I'm thinking about Slavin, Parayko, Spurgeon, Doughty, Pietrangelo, Marino, Giordano, Klefbom, Provorov, etc.

McDonagh.

Why is Matthews here?

Matthews? Hamilton? Burns?

OP is a Toronto fan lol

Zibanejad?

Not as good as these guys

Lol in a world where Matthews is "a better two-way forward" than the league leader in Shortys over the past 5 years, you know somethings wrong.

BESIDES THAT: (Take Matthews out), its actually very good.

Move Marchy up, Take out Matthews and Crosby, Put in Cerelli and someone else, and Move up Oreilly.

Matthews has definitely improved defensively but I agree that he shouldn't be on here. Cirelli is a great call for this

Doughty should be on here. He isnt great in either end anymore. Someone like ekblad or spurgeon would fit this mould perfectly

Marner isn’t that good defensively. He’s not a great shot suppressor.

Dude how you gonna take crosby out. Take Matthews out and replace him with Cirelli. Crosby is elite in his two-way game for a guy who produces as much offense as he does.

Hey man, I really didnt think that Crosby had a great defensive game but I could be wrong!!!
But yeah Matthews for Cirelli and move Marchy up
At least swap Crosby and ROR

Having watched him for so long, i think if the point of this ACGM is to have the best defensive offensive players, then Crosby should be here. He will probably never win a Selke, but he was 4th in voting last year if i remember right. you wont see him on the PK often because why risk putting your best player out there blocking shots when you can deploy other bottom 6 forwards that can do the same thing and then throw crosby out there as soon the PK is done. He does get PK time sometimes due to certain injuries and stuff. But yeah, swap ROR with Crosby, Move that 4th line to 3rd.

Wait....what? Ur telling me the #1 Scoring penalty killer, + top 20 scorer in the league isn't good enough to beat out Matthews, or MacKinnon, I mean offensively he doesn't have them beat, but he's not far behind and he's alot ahead defensively

Just because Eichel isn't here doesn't mean you have to get mad

XD...I'm not mad at all, i believe Eichel isn't a top defensive center in the NHL yet, but I don't believe that some other players in this list are better than Zibanajed. I'm not disagreeing with ur whole list just that 1 part

Zimbanajed is not better than Cirelli

Can't disagree there, but Marchand? Probably. MacKinnon? Probably. I would have Matthews and Zibanajed over those 2

Marchy biggggg no (two-way forward, one of the best defensive rankings in the league and most shortys in the last 5+ years)
But yeah Zib over mac and matthews, and eichel over all three