Both teams laugh at that offer. And ignore it.

Yeah that's a double no. Unless your pick is top5. Then its considered but not guaranteed

Even if those trades favour Montreal, i wouldn’t trade our 2 next 1st rounds pick, considering we are not contending. It would be stupid to trade 2 high picks like that

Doubt the 2021 pick is a high one. This is a pretty good team, for sure playoff bound. In terms of value, Lindholm lost value lately, he is average offensively and he'll be on his final year before UFA. I like the idea of paring him with Petry though.
As for Nylander, I do not find the offer shocking, but hey I'm completely biased anyway!

So a top 5 pick in a deep talented top draft, a great prospect who won WJC MVP last year and a responsible Middle 6 W is a bad offer?

No, it's not at all. If it's top5, then I think it's a reasonable offer for sure. Whether or not Toronto takes it, simply because nylander is on a good contract, is proven, and they are in win-now mode, I don't know, but in terms of value I'd take it.

Lindholm deal is a non starter. If and I day if they trade him they are getting more than that. My god you did not even offer a 1st this year, but next year.

Haha no. Chariot is fringe top 4, he had like 2 good months, calm down, I still think Lindholm will be a lot better next year if he can remain healthy... You'd need to add substantially like Mete (who's miles better than Chiarot) and a solid RD spec like Josh Brook

The reason both teams decline is that both teams need RhD and would only be interested in trading first-line players for at least one RhD ready to step into the #2 slot this season.

Moreover, any offer for either player starts with a 2020 first and 2020 second, plus. (Obviously, Nylander gets more than Lindholm because he's more valuable.)

Both teams hang up the phone. Lindholm is our defender