Once a Kings Fan Too
Joined: Jun. 2018
Posts: 40,208
Likes: 25,123
Ask yourself which of the players on the Buffalo side is better than ANY of the players on the Detroit side.
If the answer is "none," i.e., you have an IQ in three digits and a measurable heartbeat, then why would Detroit send you the three best players in the deal?!?
Look at this another way: Larkin, 389 NHL games; Mantha, 260 NHL games; Bertuzzi, 199 NHL games. All of them are proven performers. On the other side, we have Ristolainen (let's assume he has the value littlejerryseinfeld puts on him), a backup goaltender who is nothing more than a throw-in, Casey Mittelstadt, who has 114 games with no particular distinction, and two guys who don't even have a single game of professional hockey experience. So in return for three high-quality NHL regulars, you're sending Risto, Hutton, an undeveloped high draft pick and three prospects. I don't think that's remotely in the universe of what might laughingly be called in polite company reasonable.
Here's yet another way to look at it: if (and it's a big if) Cozens turns out to be as good as Larkin; if Mittelstadt or the first turn out to be as good as Mantha; and if Samuelsson turns out to be as good as Bertuzzi, then Detroit will be back to average, but having traded time for Risto and Hutton. In short, Detroit is assuming all of the risk here, because we all know what their trio is capable of.