@gregb569 @BradTolliverGoalie @pharrow @mhockey91 @Sidstick87 @Eugene_Meltsner @acj @NoWah49 @Marcsnack @MitchMarnerElite @ryandrisc @PakNation7 @Missouri @hockeygm @Geno_the_Hero @CHUG @Adamitis @Vlad1sko @dgfresh78 @JordanFerreira99 @Arom5477 @Marino4Norris @Yojimbo @bhavikp27 @AFOX10900 @csick @penguindude87 @PensGM2019

What do you think?

you are basically giving Murray away for nothing, while getting killed on a Gaudreau trade.

I wouldn't want Gaudreau on this team. They don't need a 5 foot nothing winger.

This whole thing is basically killing the near future of this team.
I think at this point Hallander, Poulin, and Légaré are untouchable. When this team wants to stretch out the Crosby Era past 33, those are going to be the guys doing it.

Decent prospects, nothing earth shattering but Poulin is definitely on the higher end. The picks are pretty meh.

Is Murray going to bounce back from his concussion problems, he's really slipped the last couple of seasons since ousting MAF.

Also, what is the deal with Bjugstadt? I remember a few years ago he was thought of as untouchable, anything there worth salvaging?

Pretty risky trading Gaudreau for this package, if Murray continues his downward trend the Flames will look awfully silly while Gaudreau is lighting it up on Sid or Geno's wing.

Bjugstad has been injured for the year he was with the pens. He just needs to stay healthy.
Murray should bounce back. goalies usually hit their prime around 25-28.

Well you basically traded the whole forward prospects group, but I think that’s what it will take to get Gaidreau. My concern with him is that he’s not a big game performer.

Basically giving up a lot for 2 years of Johnny Gaudreu, He walks as a free agent in 2 years to either New Jersey or Philly.

Rittich, Bennett isn't worth Murray alone, much less adding a prospect and a pick. Rittich is not even a 1B, he is a solid backup. So it's a backup and a 4th liner... that's poo for Murray.

Going with what you laid out, maybe Rittich, Bennett, 2nd for Murray.... but really I don't even want Riitich or Bennett.

quality > Quantity. Pretty easy no from Calgary IMO. Not 1 of those pieces fills a need

Too much for Johnny & not enough for Murray

Ottawa passes on your offer.

I agree with all of that but I wouldnt call anyone untouchable w/ GMJR, ..... He could trade anyone if he gets in a bad mood, LOL ... but maybe Poulin is tho

he is a crack addict when it comes to trading. Someone needs to take away the keys sometime.

that's so much for Johnny hockey, i'd rather keep those assets and throw Simon with Sid or something. Getting Rittich and Bennett wouldn't be bad tho

Also, S. Bennett is strictly a LWer now.... He has only taken like 400 Face-offs the last 3 yrs.... or an avg of 1.7 Face-offs per game .... so he is usually only playing wing & gets the occasional draw when someone gets kicked out