Quoting: Sabresforlife
Nurse is left shot Risto - Reinhart is the best player in the trade, Puljujärvi, Lavoie, and the 20th pick are all gambles, Miller while not great is a proven NHL player
- Miller is an overpaid 3rd pairing defenseman that the Oilers don't need. He has negative value in this scenario.
- Hutton is an overpaid backup with eyesight issues. Negative value.
- Pilut isn't an NHL player, better players are available in free agency for league minimum. Zero value.
- Reinhart is a good 50-60 point winger. Is he worth more than a 1st pairing defenseman? That's debatable.
- Columbus' 2020 2nd is slated to be 49th overall.
- Nurse is a 1st pairing defenseman who can PK effectively and even work the PP if asked, although he won't displace Dahlin on the 1st unit.
- Puljujarvi has some value, how much is hotly debated but he certainly has some.
- Lavoie is a hot prospect who is one of the best shot generators in the CHL.
- Edmonton's 2020 1st is slated to be 20th overall.
Also, you are sending ~$13M in cap to Edmonton but taking just $7M back. That doesn't work for Edmonton at all.