@Kotkaniemi15 @math731 @SevenLeg @Blazingbat11 @F50marco @Suzuki_Cup @Howisbergevinstillhere @Bigphil @CLR @DriveFor25 @ColonelX @HabsForEver @Campabee thoughts guys

I think Winnipeg adds a decent prospect.

Detroit passes

I personally am not big on caggiula

At 10 I would look to trade up 2 or 3 more spots to have a shot at Holtz or Perfetti

DET pass ? There is no trade, 10th OA + what MTL should add to send Mantha to MTL

Don’t get the point of mantha. At 10 my guy Quinn would be a PERFECT pick for us. Decent size, very good hands and iq and a lethal shot. Would think about maybe moving 16 but only if Jarvis and Holloway are gone.

Immediate help for Price / Weber

Not worth it for 10. Could easily sign Hoffman.

As a Detroit fan I honestly believe that nothing needs to be added because Detroit has no plans to trade Mantha.

Now I have a question for Montreal fans do you really think there is any chance Montreal gives up the 10th OA plus one of those players listed above for Mantha?

Forget it, cancer in the room and doesn't know how to play defense + he'll be looking for terms + big money

No. Those are the untouchables. I like mantha but he hasn’t proved anything

I'm trying to give quality ( not blue chip prospect, the 10th OA is the main piece ), but howisbergevinstillhaveajob is right, we should draft Quinn + Holloway for our future. It will burn another 2 years of Price and Weber but they are tanks

my bad the listed under Mantha are a no go, the listed on the left are available ( forgot Jayden Struble )

Talking about mantha seems not needed because I dont think you get 10th oa for danault anyways

With the cap not moving he’ll get 3 years. Forget the locker room thing as we truly don’t know. PP beast, lethal shot. My point was more about not moving 10

I like the WPG trade. I think they add Vesalainen and it’s a done deal. Danault would have to be extended though.
Detroit won’t trade Mantha, but having the 9th overall pick is pretty nice too.

10th

I understand and respect that. The thing I don't get is The Montreal fans that want Mantha have said a lot more bad things about in the last couple of days than all of the Detroit fans put together for the entire season.

Aa

So Danault > 10th OA
That's what I think too
Stomper why is 10th OA would be more valuable than a solid 2C coming with a decent extension ?

Not naming people, but Habs fans on this site tend to be negative about players. I think they also try and justify their **** trades

I'm sorry but I have no idea what you are trying to say.

Yes to all trade . JETS have to had a bit tho. But get hall instead of Mantha ? And use the pick to draft Lundell, or bpa? It would be a better way of managing assets. Finally, trading both Domi and Danault would leave an hell of a hole ...

I made 2 lists, the list on the left are players/picks available to add with the 10th OA and the list on the right side are players untouchable
More clear ?

Lundell gone at 9th or WPG draft him at 10 and doesn't do the trade with MTL

Kk and those with him are not available. Poehling and the others on the left of the screen are

I personally think the Jets trade is good for both teams but Id rather keep it then trade for mantha