SalarySwishSalarySwish
Forums/Armchair-GM

Rating All Brad Treliving Trades

Created by: TheFlamingC
Team: 2019-20 Calgary Flames
Initial Creation Date: Aug. 31, 2020
Published: Sep. 1, 2020
Salary Cap Mode: Basic
Description
I got this idea from somebody who did a Jim Rutherford version. I screwed up the original Hamilton trade and had him going to Boston rather than coming from Boston.
Trades
1.
CGY
    Brandon Bollig
    CHI
      2014 3rd (Matheson Iacopelli)

      Grade: B
      Bollig chewed minutes and brought grit to the Flames for two years on a cheap contract and was traded for almost nothing. Nothing went wrong
      2.
      CGY
        2015 2nd (Jeremy Lauzon)
        2015 3rd (Jens Looke)
        WSH
          Curtis Glencross

          Grade: B+
          Traded away a serviceable middle six forward for a fringe NHL player and a SHL player. It is only a B+ because Glencross only played 18 more NHL games and they were able to flip the picks for Dougie Hamilton and Oliver Kylington
          3.
          CGY
            2015 2nd (Rasmus Andersson)
            VAN
              Sven Baertschi

              Grade: A
              Traded a serviceable middle six forward for our #1 d-man. Sounds pretty good to me
              4.
              CGY
                2015 1st (Zach Senyshyn)
                2015 2nd (Jakob Forsbacka Karlsson)
                2015 2nd (Jeremy Luazon)
                BOS
                  Dougie Hamilton

                  Grade: A+
                  No pick traded away has logged significant NHL minutes. Forsbacka Karlsson played in the SHL, Lauzon is a fringe NHLer and Senyshyn has been an AHL player. We got the NHL's scoring leader as a defensemen.
                  5.
                  CGY
                    2015 2nd (Oliver Kylington)
                    ARI
                      2015 3rd (Adin Hill)
                      2015 3rd (Jens Looke)

                      Grade: B
                      Adin Hill is going to become a good NHL goalie. Jens Looke plays in the SHL and Oliver Kylington might still peak as a top 4 d-man. If not then he can be a 4-5
                      6.
                      CGY
                        2016 2nd (Tyler Parsons)
                        2018 4th (Demetrious Koumontzis)
                        FLA
                          Jiri Hudler

                          Grade: C
                          Was terrific with the Flames and never found his footing after. Parsons and Koumontzis are both meh prospects. Lateral move.
                          7.
                          CGY
                            Jyrki Jokipakka
                            Brett Pollock
                            2016 2nd (Dillon Dube)
                            DAL
                              Kris Russell

                              Grade: A-
                              Russell was a good 4-5 d-man. We got a promising young player in Dube though so we definitely won.
                              8.
                              CGY
                                Niklas Backstrom
                                2016 6th (Matthew Phillips)
                                MIN
                                  David Jones

                                  Grade: B
                                  Meh rental for meh rental but we get a promising young prospect who will likely peak as second line winger
                                  9.
                                  CGY
                                    Brain Elliott
                                    STL
                                      2016 2nd (Jordan Kyrou)
                                      2018 cond. 3rd (stayed with Calgary)

                                      Grade: C+
                                      Elliott was terrific for Calgary and got us to the playoffs (where we were swept but sill playoffs). Kyrou is a promising young prospect. The Blues are going to get a lot more use of Kyrou then we got of Elliott but Elliott served us well.
                                      10.
                                      CGY
                                        2017 3rd (Stuart Skinner)
                                        2018 5th (Akira Schmid)
                                        ARI
                                          Michael Stone

                                          Grade: B-
                                          Stone was and still is a very good 5-6 d-man for the Flames. Stuart skinner however is a promising young goalie prospect for Edmonton. While he is promising, he isn't there yet so the trade remains a B. If Skinner becomes a good goalie, it could become a C depending on Skinner's success.
                                          11.
                                          CGY
                                            Curtis Lazar
                                            Michael Kostka
                                            OTT
                                              Jyrki Jokipakka
                                              2017 2nd (Alex Formenton)

                                              Grade: D+
                                              The first clear loss. Jokipakka only played 3 more games in the NHL but Formenton is going to become a good middle six forward for years and Lazar scored 15 points for the Flames in 70 games. Bad trade.
                                              12.
                                              CGY
                                                Mike Smith
                                                ARI
                                                  Chad Johnson
                                                  Brandon Hickey
                                                  2018 3rd (Niklas Nordgren)

                                                  Grade: A
                                                  The 3 players traded never played a game for Arizona. Smith had one terrific season, one awful season and one terrific playoff stint. We got him for essentially free so it was a great trade.
                                                  13.
                                                  CGY
                                                    Travis Hamonic
                                                    2019 4th (Lucas Feuk)
                                                    NYI
                                                      2018 1st (Noah Dobson)
                                                      2018 2nd (Ruslan Iskhakov)
                                                      2019 2nd (Samuel Bolduc)

                                                      Grade: B-
                                                      I think that this was a win-win but that is a bit of a reach. There were upsides but downsides. 3 promising prospects, one of which will certainly be a top d-man for years to come. 2 others are just promising prospects. Hamonic has so far had 3 very productive seasons for Calgary and maybe more. This trade could be drastically improved with an extension or become a disaster if he walks and all 3 develop into good NHLers.
                                                      14.
                                                      CGY
                                                        Eddie Lack
                                                        Ryan Murphy
                                                        2019 7th (Dustin Wolf)
                                                        CAR
                                                          Keegan Kanzig
                                                          2019 6th (Kevin Wall)

                                                          Grade: C+
                                                          We traded an ECHL player and a player who lit up the BCHL but struggled in the Big-10 for 4 combined games with the Flames. This one won't have a winner determined for years to come but Dustin Wolf looks to be a great goaltending prospect. Wall could regain his BCHL form. I'm just going to give it a C+ for now because we really don't know.
                                                          15.
                                                          CGY
                                                            Dalton Prout
                                                            NJD
                                                              Eddie Lack

                                                              Grade: C+
                                                              Prout was the Flames 7th D for one year and Lack only played 4 more NHL games. We won but neither team actually benefitted too much.
                                                              16.
                                                              CGY
                                                                Elias Lindholm
                                                                Noah Hanifin
                                                                CAR
                                                                  Michael Ferland
                                                                  Dougie Hamilton
                                                                  Adam Fox

                                                                  Grade: A
                                                                  The trade that will define Treliving's tenure with the Flames. Ferland played one year with Carolina, Hamilton has become one of the NHL's top 15 d-men and Adam Fox refused to sign anywhere but New York. Lindholm is the Flames top RW and Hanifin a top pairing d-man. Sucks to lose Ferland, Fox and Hamilton but Ferland and Fox were going to go anyways.
                                                                  17.
                                                                  CGY
                                                                    Rinat Valiev
                                                                    Matt Toarmina
                                                                    MTL
                                                                      Brett Kulak

                                                                      Grade: F-
                                                                      Disaster trade. A good 4-5 d-man for 2 career AHLers
                                                                      18.
                                                                      CGY
                                                                        Oscar Fantenberg
                                                                        LAK
                                                                          2020 4th

                                                                          Grade: C
                                                                          Chewed useful minutes for Calgary. Nothing bad, nothing good.
                                                                          19.
                                                                          CGY
                                                                            Milan Lucic
                                                                            2020 3rd
                                                                            EDM
                                                                              James Neal

                                                                              Grade: C-
                                                                              The NHL's worst player for a just about 20 goal scorer. Sound pretty bad on paper but we weren't using Neal properly and we used Lucic pretty well. Started to sort of heat up in the playoffs and end of season. Brought some useful hits and energy and what-not. Still think he should be banished from Calgary but not as much a disaster as previously thought.
                                                                              20.
                                                                              CGY
                                                                                2020 4th
                                                                                BUF
                                                                                  Michael Frolik

                                                                                  Grade: F
                                                                                  Reportedly didn't get along with Bill Peters but he's gone so no point to make this trade. He was expiring but he was still a good middle six winger. He was expensive and we needed space for the deadline but didn't make any deals so this was pointless.
                                                                                  21.
                                                                                  CGY
                                                                                    Derek Forbort
                                                                                    LAK
                                                                                      2021 4th

                                                                                      Grade: C-
                                                                                      We needed an extra defensemen for the stretch and he chewed useful minutes
                                                                                      22.
                                                                                      CGY
                                                                                        Erik Gustafsson
                                                                                        CHI
                                                                                          2020 3rd

                                                                                          Grade: B-
                                                                                          Sneaky good pickup. 7 points in 17 games. Hope he resigns.
                                                                                          23.
                                                                                          CGY
                                                                                          ANA
                                                                                            Overall Grade: B-
                                                                                            Buyouts
                                                                                            Buried
                                                                                            DraftRound 1Round 2Round 3Round 4Round 5Round 6Round 7
                                                                                            2020
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the EDM
                                                                                            Logo of the SJS
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            2021
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            2022
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            Logo of the CGY
                                                                                            ROSTER SIZESALARY CAPCAP HITOVERAGES TooltipBONUSESCAP SPACE
                                                                                            25$81,500,000$72,079,625$0$747,500$9,420,375
                                                                                            Left WingCentreRight Wing
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $7,000,000$7,000,000
                                                                                            RW
                                                                                            UFA - 3
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $6,375,000$6,375,000
                                                                                            C, LW, RW
                                                                                            UFA - 4
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $4,850,000$4,850,000
                                                                                            C, RW
                                                                                            UFA - 5
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $6,750,000$6,750,000
                                                                                            LW
                                                                                            UFA - 3
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $5,350,000$5,350,000
                                                                                            C
                                                                                            NTC
                                                                                            UFA - 5
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $778,333$778,333 (Performance Bonus$182,500$182K)
                                                                                            LW, RW, C
                                                                                            RFA - 2
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $5,250,000$5,250,000
                                                                                            LW, RW
                                                                                            NMC
                                                                                            UFA - 4
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $3,125,000$3,125,000
                                                                                            C, RW
                                                                                            UFA - 2
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $700,000$700,000
                                                                                            RW, LW
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $1,675,000$1,675,000
                                                                                            C, LW
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $2,550,000$2,550,000
                                                                                            C
                                                                                            UFA - 2
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $715,000$715,000
                                                                                            RW, LW
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $700,000$700,000
                                                                                            LW
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Left DefenseRight DefenseGoaltender
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $3,375,000$3,375,000
                                                                                            LD
                                                                                            NTC
                                                                                            UFA - 3
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $4,650,400$4,650,400
                                                                                            LD/RD
                                                                                            M-NTC
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $1,375,000$1,375,000
                                                                                            G
                                                                                            UFA - 2
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $1,237,500$1,237,500
                                                                                            LD
                                                                                            UFA - 5
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $3,857,143$3,857,143
                                                                                            RD
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $2,750,000$2,750,000
                                                                                            G
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $1,893,750$1,893,750
                                                                                            LD
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $755,833$755,833 (Performance Bonus$57,500$58K)
                                                                                            RD
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $1,200,000$1,200,000
                                                                                            LD
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $700,000$700,000
                                                                                            RD
                                                                                            UFA - 1
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $894,166$894,166 (Performance Bonus$425,000$425K)
                                                                                            LD
                                                                                            RFA - 2
                                                                                            Logo of the Calgary Flames
                                                                                            $730,833$730,833 (Performance Bonus$82,500$82K)
                                                                                            LD/RD
                                                                                            UFA - 1

                                                                                            Embed Code

                                                                                            • To display this team on another website or blog, add this iFrame to the appropriate page
                                                                                            • Customize the height attribute in the iFrame code below to fit your website appropriately. Minimum recommended: 400px.

                                                                                            Text-Embed

                                                                                            Click to Highlight
                                                                                            Sep. 4, 2020 at 10:03 a.m.
                                                                                            #26
                                                                                            Banned
                                                                                            Avatar of the user
                                                                                            Joined: May 2017
                                                                                            Posts: 4,561
                                                                                            Likes: 1,266
                                                                                            Quoting: TheFlamingC
                                                                                            Okay, wasn't aware of those details. I still think it's an A+ as they will likely peak at 3rd line or 3rd pair.


                                                                                            I think it was a terrific trade for yall too! Just needed to make sure you knew the bruins guys tho to reevaluate
                                                                                            TheFlamingC liked this.
                                                                                             
                                                                                            Reply
                                                                                            To create a post please Login or Register
                                                                                            Question:
                                                                                            Options:
                                                                                            Add Option
                                                                                            Submit Poll