Joined: May 2015
Posts: 19,538
Likes: 6,693
Usually when you make an offer, you need to look at the other teams needs to understand what they would want in return for "X" player. Assuming that player is someone their team would trade. Lindholm isn't a player they're moving so not sure why you think they'd trade him to begin with?
This trade doesnt make sense for CGY, like at all. It makes sense for MTL. Thats the problem. Who cares whose better or more valauble. You havent even correctly identified a player a team would even entertain moving. (Barring massive unrealistic overpayment in which any player is available then)