Given Guerin’s recent trades Minnesota probably adds like Khovanov and a 1st

I just don't see Monahan getting traded for Dumba. That leaves Calgary to weak up the middle. I could see Calgary offering Johnny and Janko for Dumba and Greenway perhaps. with a sweetener.

That would be horrible for Calgary dumba is too 4 at best and Johnny is an elite players

That trade is horrible for Calgary they easily decline

Again you’re not getting much more for Monahan and Kunin is a pretty good young player who can play C/RW, Calgary’s two biggest weaknesses on offense

It’s absolutely fair value.

My guy just straight up copied my trade scenario with the smallest change lol.

Didn’t even see it tbh lol

I agree Johnny is an elite player. That's why I said Dumba plus Greenway plus a sweetner (prospect , pick or both). The main point was I don't see Monahan getting traded like the original proposal, unless a strong Centre is coming back or Tre has a trade for one.

Johnny is a great player. He will get you to the playoffs by getting points and wins. I just don't think his game is suited to playoff hockey which is a heavy game. He either needs to change that aspect of his game, or play or a different style of team (Tampa). His game is not to play the small forward game Theo did. I think Johnny does need to go in on the D man and push him or lean on him to wear him down. I didn't see that against either the Jets or Dallas. Additionally, if any of the other CGY rumors happen (ie, Markstrom, Murray, etc) Calgary will need to create cap space. Other than Lucic (who has limited value), how do you see CGY doing it? You have a reduced schedule this coming season and with 16.9 m is cap space. They need a goalie, four forward positions and three d positions. That's just over 2 m a player and a bit of cap space to spare. Mangiapane is getting paid this time. You need a stronger goalie so that going to be 3-6 m, to help share the work load with Rittich. When you start looking at the Cap numbers someone needs to go out so they can start filling holes. Johnny has the best value to give GCY the best return. At this time the return is unknown. We are likely losing Hamonic so we need a more physical D-man Dumba fits that need. Greenway is a big which CGY also needs some more of. If Johnny moves on, scoring will need to be more by committee moving forwards. You are banking Mangiapane and Dube keep progressing.

Perhaps Johnny stays, so be, it he is still a great player and Tre uses UFA's to fill those holes with value deals. AT this point only Tre knows.