SalarySwishSalarySwish
Forums/Armchair-GM

No Regrets On The Tavares Signing

Created by: AnalyticsGeek
Team: 2020-21 Toronto Maple Leafs
Initial Creation Date: Nov. 27, 2020
Published: Nov. 27, 2020
Salary Cap Mode: Basic
Description
I don’t understand how anyone can think the Tavares signing was a mistake. To me, that’s just an irresponsible & uneducated way of evaluating the Leafs’ situation. Tavares is a franchise level center who consistently ranks in the top 2-3% league wide in generating shot attempts & scoring chances. He’s consistently scored at 70-80 point rates on horrendous Islander teams. He is well worth the money. Where the Leafs went wrong was:

1. Not trading Kadri while he had peak value for a number 1 defenceman. They could’ve easily sent Kadri, a prospect & a 1st for a top tier defenceman like Hamilton, Spurgeon or Ellis.

2. Overpay Marner by around 2 million. With that extra cap space, the Leafs could've easily afforded to add a top right-handed defenceman.

People are being too harsh on a superstar for having 1 season below his usual expectation (still scored at a 34 goal 78 point pace). It’s easy to look at his age and cap hit and be influenced that he is the problem, but oftentimes we need to go deeper than that.

In conclusion, the Leafs got a franchise level number 1 center for free. He is still in his prime and there should be no regrets about his signing whatsoever.
Free Agent Signings
CREATEDYEARSCAP HIT
Marner, Mitchell
4$9,000,000
Trades
1.
NSH
    Nazem Kadri
    Timothy Liljegren
    2020 1st Round Pick

    *Done During 2018 Offseason
    2.
    FLA
      Kasperi Kapanen
      Travis Dermott

      *Done During 2020 Offseason
      3.
      TOR
        Alexander Kerfoot
        COL
          Semyon Der-Arguchintsev
          2021 2nd Round Pick

          *Done After Avs Drafted Newhook
          Retained Salary Transactions
          DraftRound 1Round 2Round 3Round 4Round 5Round 6Round 7
          2021
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          2022
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          2023
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          Logo of the TOR
          ROSTER SIZESALARY CAPCAP HITOVERAGES TooltipBONUSESCAP SPACE
          22$81,500,000$81,238,450$0$0$261,550

          Roster

          Left WingCentreRight Wing
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $2,250,000$2,250,000
          RW, LW
          M-NTC
          UFA - 1
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $11,640,250$11,640,250
          C
          UFA - 4
          Marner, Mitchell
          $9,000,000$9,000,000
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $1,645,000$1,645,000
          LW, RW
          UFA - 2
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $11,000,000$11,000,000
          C, LW
          NMC
          UFA - 5
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $6,962,366$6,962,366
          RW
          UFA - 4
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $900,000$900,000
          RW, LW
          UFA - 1
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $3,500,000$3,500,000
          LW, C, RW
          UFA - 3
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $925,000$925,000
          RW, LW
          UFA - 1
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $821,667$821,667
          LW, RW
          RFA - 4
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $700,000$700,000
          C, LW
          NMC
          UFA - 1
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $700,000$700,000
          C, RW
          UFA - 1
          Left DefenseRight DefenseGoaltender
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $5,000,000$5,000,000
          LD
          M-NTC
          UFA - 2
          Logo of the Nashville Predators
          $6,250,000$6,250,000
          RD
          UFA - 7
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $5,000,000$5,000,000
          G
          M-NTC
          UFA - 1
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $5,625,000$5,625,000
          LD
          NMC
          UFA - 4
          Logo of the Florida Panthers
          $3,250,000$3,250,000
          LD/RD
          UFA - 3
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $1,650,000$1,650,000
          G
          UFA - 2
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $894,167$894,167
          LD
          UFA - 2
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $925,000$925,000
          LD
          UFA - 1
          ScratchesInjured Reserve (IR)Long Term IR (LTIR)
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $700,000$700,000
          C, RW
          UFA - 1
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $1,500,000$1,500,000
          RW, LW
          NTC
          UFA - 1
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $700,000$700,000
          LD
          UFA - 1
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $1,250,000$1,250,000
          RW, LW
          UFA - 2
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $10,903,000$10,903,000
          RW
          UFA - 5
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $5,000,000$5,000,000
          LD/RD
          NMC
          UFA - 4
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $2,000,000$2,000,000
          RD
          M-NTC
          UFA - 3
          Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
          $1,000,000$1,000,000
          RD
          NTC
          UFA - 1

          Embed Code

          • To display this team on another website or blog, add this iFrame to the appropriate page
          • Customize the height attribute in the iFrame code below to fit your website appropriately. Minimum recommended: 400px.

          Text-Embed

          Click to Highlight
          Nov. 27, 2020 at 10:18 p.m.
          #26
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Mar. 2020
          Posts: 2,679
          Likes: 696
          Wouldn’t be you if you didn’t adjust the Marner contract
          Nov. 27, 2020 at 10:42 p.m.
          #27
          Hidalgo
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Apr. 2019
          Posts: 481
          Likes: 223
          I also made a really long post on this, lots of the same ideas in tons of depth.

          At the end of the day it was a great move at the time and now. Anyone who says otherwise is just nitpicking/a revisionist/a leafs hater/ a contrarian. 98% of signings you could make a negative argument about, but signing a top 5-10 Centre in the league is a no brainer at any price. Once you analyze the other FA and trade options in the last 2 years, the argument is over,
          Nov. 27, 2020 at 11:10 p.m.
          #28
          Ovchinnikov 137
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Apr. 2019
          Posts: 10,412
          Likes: 11,982
          In 2017, the Leafs had the second best power play percentage (25%) and were tied with Pittsburgh in goals for per game (3.29). Their defence was terrible, giving up the 4th highest shots per game (33.9). Addressing their brutal defence would have been the smarter play. Instead, they signed John Tavares to an 11 mil contract which had a trickledown effect on signing Matthews and Marner. So what if Nylander held out and they miss the playoffs. This team was incredible young. Slowly building a core around Matthews, Marner, and Nylander was the right play to make. Look at how great Colorado is building around their core of guys (Mackinnon, Landeskog, Rantanen). Without Tavares the Leafs would have had about 20 mil to work with before placing Horton on LTIR that season. More than enough to sign a dman or trade for one, while still continually building.

          The Leafs already their future no. 1 center in Auston Matthews, so the addition of John Tavares created more complications for them. The Leafs had one of the brightest futures in the NHL led by their young core and in about 10 years into the future, they were projected to be on top of the league. However, when Tavares signed with the Leafs, their status changed from a future dynasty to a win-now phase.
          Tavares is obviously a very skilled and gifted player, the decision of signing with the Maple Leafs will end up ruining their future due to him not being a positional fit, taking up a large amount of cap space and rushing their timeline to win the Stanley Cup.
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 12:29 p.m.
          #29
          Hockey God Genius
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Jun. 2015
          Posts: 3,260
          Likes: 810
          Im Pens fan but I am also a big fan of Marner (The next Kessel who will get moved to PIT in a yr) lol.

          But seriously I think it was a HUGE mistake signing JT to a long contract, now if it was a 1 or 2 yr Deal when he signed until Matthews was ready to take over as the #1, I would have agreed to that.

          Having 4 Forwards taking up 50% of the Cap is just INSANE.

          If I was a Toronto fan I would want to try to Trade JT this off-season while his value is still high & get a better team for it.

          Lets just use MIN as an Example
          J.T. & Liljegren
          For
          - C- Stall (bf he was traded)
          - RHD- Dumba
          - Boldy
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 1:58 p.m.
          #30
          Thread Starter
          Banned
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Sep. 2019
          Posts: 5,011
          Likes: 1,636
          Quoting: palhal
          Getting Tavares for free as UFA at 11m was fine. At time of signing...overpaying Nylander 500,000 (see Pastarak as a comparable). No way Matthews should be 2nd highest player in the league. A five year term should have been a 9.5m contract...so that's 2m overpay. Aho and Marner had identical stats for two years....Marner was 9m contract for six years, so a 2m
          That's 4.5m. that could have used to keep Kadri and made over moves


          Yes I agree the Leafs could’ve saved some money on the RFA signings and kept Kadri while adding someone like DeMelo.
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 2:03 p.m.
          #31
          Thread Starter
          Banned
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Sep. 2019
          Posts: 5,011
          Likes: 1,636
          Quoting: MMXD
          Wouldn’t be you if you didn’t adjust the Marner contract


          Well I adjusted Marner’s contract to show his overpay was part of the problem for Toronto’s failures so far.
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 2:04 p.m.
          #32
          Thread Starter
          Banned
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Sep. 2019
          Posts: 5,011
          Likes: 1,636
          Quoting: Hidalgo
          I also made a really long post on this, lots of the same ideas in tons of depth.

          At the end of the day it was a great move at the time and now. Anyone who says otherwise is just nitpicking/a revisionist/a leafs hater/ a contrarian. 98% of signings you could make a negative argument about, but signing a top 5-10 Centre in the league is a no brainer at any price. Once you analyze the other FA and trade options in the last 2 years, the argument is over,


          Yes I agree. You basically get a franchise level without having to give up any assets, you take that every time.
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 2:16 p.m.
          #33
          Thread Starter
          Banned
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Sep. 2019
          Posts: 5,011
          Likes: 1,636
          Quoting: LeafsfanMathews
          In 2017, the Leafs had the second best power play percentage (25%) and were tied with Pittsburgh in goals for per game (3.29). Their defence was terrible, giving up the 4th highest shots per game (33.9). Addressing their brutal defence would have been the smarter play. Instead, they signed John Tavares to an 11 mil contract which had a trickledown effect on signing Matthews and Marner. So what if Nylander held out and they miss the playoffs. This team was incredible young. Slowly building a core around Matthews, Marner, and Nylander was the right play to make. Look at how great Colorado is building around their core of guys (Mackinnon, Landeskog, Rantanen). Without Tavares the Leafs would have had about 20 mil to work with before placing Horton on LTIR that season. More than enough to sign a dman or trade for one, while still continually building.

          The Leafs already their future no. 1 center in Auston Matthews, so the addition of John Tavares created more complications for them. The Leafs had one of the brightest futures in the NHL led by their young core and in about 10 years into the future, they were projected to be on top of the league. However, when Tavares signed with the Leafs, their status changed from a future dynasty to a win-now phase.
          Tavares is obviously a very skilled and gifted player, the decision of signing with the Maple Leafs will end up ruining their future due to him not being a positional fit, taking up a large amount of cap space and rushing their timeline to win the Stanley Cup.


          I guess it’s fair to say that adding a big salary superstar veteran in Tavares complicated their rebuild and caused some confusion to the direction the team wanted to head towards. However, by signing him, they gained an additional elite center asset which should’ve given them insurance to trade someone like Kadri for an elite defenceman. The fact that the Leafs didn’t take advantage of that is where I felt they went wrong. Cuz if you get to add a franchise center as a free agent, you do it every time and move other pieces to accommodate it.
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 4:54 p.m.
          #34
          Hidalgo
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Apr. 2019
          Posts: 481
          Likes: 223
          Quoting: LeafsfanMathews
          In 2017, the Leafs had the second best power play percentage (25%) and were tied with Pittsburgh in goals for per game (3.29). Their defence was terrible, giving up the 4th highest shots per game (33.9). Addressing their brutal defence would have been the smarter play. Instead, they signed John Tavares to an 11 mil contract which had a trickledown effect on signing Matthews and Marner. So what if Nylander held out and they miss the playoffs. This team was incredible young. Slowly building a core around Matthews, Marner, and Nylander was the right play to make. Look at how great Colorado is building around their core of guys (Mackinnon, Landeskog, Rantanen). Without Tavares the Leafs would have had about 20 mil to work with before placing Horton on LTIR that season. More than enough to sign a dman or trade for one, while still continually building.

          The Leafs already their future no. 1 center in Auston Matthews, so the addition of John Tavares created more complications for them. The Leafs had one of the brightest futures in the NHL led by their young core and in about 10 years into the future, they were projected to be on top of the league. However, when Tavares signed with the Leafs, their status changed from a future dynasty to a win-now phase.
          Tavares is obviously a very skilled and gifted player, the decision of signing with the Maple Leafs will end up ruining their future due to him not being a positional fit, taking up a large amount of cap space and rushing their timeline to win the Stanley Cup.


          It was a free franchise player. If Toronto had the opportunity to get Tavares at a reduced price for what he could’ve got and they passed up on him, with any explanation of not wanted to accelerate their rebuild, people would be calling for Dubas’s head for his entire career. This is classic revisionist history “everything Toronto does is bad” attitudes that people put out there and then everyone else buys into. F’ed if you don’t, f’ed if you do. Also just based on the trade pieces you gain by signing Tavares, that is also a gain.
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 4:58 p.m.
          #35
          Hidalgo
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Apr. 2019
          Posts: 481
          Likes: 223
          Quoting: Sidstick87
          Im Pens fan but I am also a big fan of Marner (The next Kessel who will get moved to PIT in a yr) lol.

          But seriously I think it was a HUGE mistake signing JT to a long contract, now if it was a 1 or 2 yr Deal when he signed until Matthews was ready to take over as the #1, I would have agreed to that.

          Having 4 Forwards taking up 50% of the Cap is just INSANE.

          If I was a Toronto fan I would want to try to Trade JT this off-season while his value is still high & get a better team for it.

          Lets just use MIN as an Example
          J.T. & Liljegren
          For
          - C- Stall (bf he was traded)
          - RHD- Dumba
          - Boldy


          Based on this idea, doesn’t the fact that Toronto got over 80 goals out of Tavares, 2 playoff appearances, and now have a trade asset that can be used for an elite dman (their supposed biggest need), make the signing not a mistake?
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 5:54 p.m.
          #36
          Ovchinnikov 137
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Apr. 2019
          Posts: 10,412
          Likes: 11,982
          Quoting: MitchMarnerElite
          I guess it’s fair to say that adding a big salary superstar veteran in Tavares complicated their rebuild and caused some confusion to the direction the team wanted to head towards. However, by signing him, they gained an additional elite center asset which should’ve given them insurance to trade someone like Kadri for an elite defenceman. The fact that the Leafs didn’t take advantage of that is where I felt they went wrong. Cuz if you get to add a franchise center as a free agent, you do it every time and move other pieces to accommodate it.


          I get the narrative that when a franchise superstar comes available in FA you try to go after him. Players like JT don’t hit FA hardly ever. And if you can acquire a player like him it’s usually by trade and your giving up multiple picks and prospects to do so. But the Leafs also already had a potent duo at center with Matthews and Nazem Kadri. Following his 40-goal, 69-point Calder Trophy-winning season, Matthews had 34 goals and 29 assists in 62 games that season while Kadri was trying to improve on two consecutive 32-goal seasons. TAVARES WAS NOT NEEDED. You can’t sit here and even say the Leafs are better with him. They still haven’t won a playoff series in he’s first two years. Even there record is worse:
          2016 40-27
          2017 49-26
          2018 46-28
          2019 36-25
          Why do you think you see so many Nylander and Marner trades on here, finding cap space and improving the Dcore. Tavares is awesome but HE WAS NOT NEEDED
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 6:27 p.m.
          #37
          Thread Starter
          Banned
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Sep. 2019
          Posts: 5,011
          Likes: 1,636
          Edited Nov. 28, 2020 at 6:34 p.m.
          Quoting: LeafsfanMathews
          I get the narrative that when a franchise superstar comes available in FA you try to go after him. Players like JT don’t hit FA hardly ever. And if you can acquire a player like him it’s usually by trade and your giving up multiple picks and prospects to do so. But the Leafs also already had a potent duo at center with Matthews and Nazem Kadri. Following his 40-goal, 69-point Calder Trophy-winning season, Matthews had 34 goals and 29 assists in 62 games that season while Kadri was trying to improve on two consecutive 32-goal seasons. TAVARES WAS NOT NEEDED. You can’t sit here and even say the Leafs are better with him. They still haven’t won a playoff series in he’s first two years. Even there record is worse:
          2016 40-27
          2017 49-26
          2018 46-28
          2019 36-25
          Why do you think you see so many Nylander and Marner trades on here, finding cap space and improving the Dcore. Tavares is awesome but HE WAS NOT NEEDED


          I agree that he wasn’t needed, but even while adding him, they could’ve found ways to improve the defence. Tavares is better than all of Kadri, Nylander and Marner. Any one of those guys could’ve been dealt for an elite defenceman (ie Kadri for Ellis or Nylander for Theodore). It was a matter of them not making a move like that which became the issue.

          Anyway, I saw a post about how ever since Keefe took over the Leafs, they have been a middle of the road team defensively (they ranked 27th in save percentage). Considering they had Ceci, Barrie & Marincin playing big minutes (all of whom were pretty bad), that’s pretty good. This season with the addition of Brodie and possibly a breakout season from Dermott, this team should be much improved from last season.
          MatthewsFan liked this.
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 6:52 p.m.
          #38
          Ovchinnikov 137
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Apr. 2019
          Posts: 10,412
          Likes: 11,982
          Quoting: MitchMarnerElite
          I agree that he wasn’t needed, but even while adding him, they could’ve found ways to improve the defence. Tavares is better than all of Kadri, Nylander and Marner. Any one of those guys could’ve been dealt for an elite defenceman (ie Kadri for Ellis or Nylander for Theodore). It was a matter of them not making a move like that which became the issue.

          Anyway, I saw a post about how ever since Keefe took over the Leafs, they have been a middle of the road team defensively (they ranked 27th in save percentage). Considering they had Ceci, Barrie & Marincin playing big minutes (all of whom were pretty bad), that’s pretty good. This season with the addition of Brodie and possibly a breakout season from Dermott, this team should be much improved from last season.


          I am super optimistic about how this season could play out. I love the additions Dubas made and even more so since there will be an all Canadian division and even the first playoff round the Leafs have a legit shot this year. But the flat cap (pandemic’s fault, no way the Leafs could have seen this) will force them to probably deal away one of or multiple key players off this roster. Which just makes having JT’s 11mil even worse. All I know is, whenever I look at the Avs, I really believe that could have been the Leafs.
          Nov. 28, 2020 at 7:50 p.m.
          #39
          Thread Starter
          Banned
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Sep. 2019
          Posts: 5,011
          Likes: 1,636
          Quoting: LeafsfanMathews
          I am super optimistic about how this season could play out. I love the additions Dubas made and even more so since there will be an all Canadian division and even the first playoff round the Leafs have a legit shot this year. But the flat cap (pandemic’s fault, no way the Leafs could have seen this) will force them to probably deal away one of or multiple key players off this roster. Which just makes having JT’s 11mil even worse. All I know is, whenever I look at the Avs, I really believe that could have been the Leafs.


          Yeah no doubt it will be difficult for the Leafs to make the cap work under a flat cap after 2020/21 with as much money committed into the big 4 as they have. Even if Dermott establishes himself as the number 4 D, they still need to add depth and a goaltender which they have very little money to do so.

          I don’t think anyone wants to touch Marner, so most likely it will need to be Nylander that gets moved. Although it would probably be for players on ELC.
          Nov. 30, 2020 at 9:09 p.m.
          #40
          Avatar of the user
          Joined: Mar. 2020
          Posts: 2,679
          Likes: 696
          Quoting: MitchMarnerElite
          Well I adjusted Marner’s contract to show his overpay was part of the problem for Toronto’s failures so far.


          He’s not even that overpaid 😂
           
          Reply
          To create a post please Login or Register
          Question:
          Options:
          Add Option
          Submit Poll