Who is better

Romanov for Calder

Joined: Jul 2020

Posts: 2,449

Likes: 998

@Capitalfail67 Let's see what everyone else thinks

Nov 28, 2020 at 4:48

#2

Zuki9797

Not JoshAnderson17

Joined: Feb 2019

Posts: 8,439

Likes: 2,483

Crosby
Josi

mhockey91 and oilersguy liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 4:48

#3

Joined: May 2018

Posts: 17,413

Likes: 5,649

Left. Not close.

HabsFan9, HadesOfSoCal, Kotkaniemi15 and 2 others liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 4:50

#4

Thread Starter

Romanov for Calder

Joined: Jul 2020

Posts: 2,449

Likes: 998

Quoting: Bcarlo25

Left. Not close.

I agree entirely

aedoran liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 4:50

#5

Thread Starter

Romanov for Calder

Joined: Jul 2020

Posts: 2,449

Likes: 998

Quoting: Bcarlo25

Left. Not close.[/quo

Double post

Nov 28, 2020 at 4:53

#6

Kotkaniemi15

Its pretty mint.

Joined: Jun 2017

Posts: 7,849

Likes: 4,251

Clearly Hedman & Crosby.

HabsFan9, mhockey91 and aedoran liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 4:57

#7

hockeyconnor97

Connor

Joined: Oct 2018

Posts: 936

Likes: 353

I don't think Corsby vs malkin is even a debate, and I would choose Hedman (but Josi was better this year)

bhavikp27, aedoran and Kotkaniemi15 liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 4:59

#8

villenash

Joined: May 2019

Posts: 4,434

Likes: 2,591

Coming from a Preds fan, I'd say Crosby + Josi.

But Hedman/Josi are 1 and 2 in the NHL I think. Close though.

Jeuck75, AndrewLadd and Capitalfail67 liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 5:12

#9

Jeuck75

Joined: Jul 2019

Posts: 1,969

Likes: 614

Crosby
Josi (but if you said Hedman I wouldn't argue)

Capitalfail67 liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 5:55

#10

ForsbergForVezina

Sorokin SZN

Joined: May 2018

Posts: 3,520

Likes: 1,588

Crosby
Hedman

Nov 28, 2020 at 6:28

#11

Caps fan idk why

Joined: Dec 2016

Posts: 8,468

Likes: 3,115

Crosby vs Malkin last 2 year

120gp....51g 96a 147points p/60 3.543.......xGF% 54.76

Malkin (merely a 2c but sid is the best player in the NHL lol )

123gp.....46g 100a 146 points p/60 3.724......xGF% 54.82

Hedman and Josi are both really good. You are crying that Hedman is hands down the best Dman in the nhl and he’s “under rated “ bc he didn’t win the Norris. It’s just an idiotic take.

Remember you called Crosby underrated. You also called Malkin “merely a 2c”

mhockey91 liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 6:30

#12

Caps fan idk why

Joined: Dec 2016

Posts: 8,468

Likes: 3,115

Edited Nov 28, 2020 at 6:39

Quoting: hockeyconnor97

I don't think Corsby vs malkin is even a debate, and I would choose Hedman (but Josi was better this year)

Quoting: Kotkaniemi15

Clearly Hedman & Crosby.

Quoting: Bcarlo25

Left. Not close.

Last 2 years it’s actually fairly close.

Crosby vs Malkin last 2 year

120gp....51g 96a 147points p/60 3.543.......xGF% 54.76

Malkin

123gp.....46g 100a 146 points p/60 3.724......xGF% 54.82

Crosby is the easy answer and probably had the better career but recently Malkin is just as good if not better.

Hedman

53.27CF%...53.51FF%......55.91xGF% 55points

Josi

53.40CF%......54.10FF%.....62.18xGF% 65 points

“Clearly”

mhockey91 liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 6:34

#13

Keaton1117

Joined: Aug 2020

Posts: 104

Likes: 24

Left side

Nov 28, 2020 at 6:45

#14

Joined: May 2018

Posts: 17,413

Likes: 5,649

Quoting: Capitalfail67

Last 2 years it’s actually fairly close.

Crosby vs Malkin last 2 year

120gp....51g 96a 147points p/60 3.543.......xGF% 54.76

Malkin

123gp.....46g 100a 146 points p/60 3.724......xGF% 54.82

Crosby is the easy answer and probably had the better career but recently Malkin is just as good if not better.

Hedman

53.27CF%...53.51FF%......55.91xGF% 55points

Josi

53.40CF%......54.10FF%.....62.18xGF% 65 points

“Clearly”

If you want to reduce it to that.

If you’re talking about playing hockey, it’s Crosby and Hedman, and its not close.

HabsFan9 liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 7:18

#15

Thread Starter

Romanov for Calder

Joined: Jul 2020

Posts: 2,449

Likes: 998

Quoting: Capitalfail67

Crosby vs Malkin last 2 year

120gp....51g 96a 147points p/60 3.543.......xGF% 54.76

Malkin (merely a 2c but sid is the best player in the NHL lol )

123gp.....46g 100a 146 points p/60 3.724......xGF% 54.82

Hedman and Josi are both really good. You are crying that Hedman is hands down the best Dman in the nhl and he’s “under rated “ bc he didn’t win the Norris. It’s just an idiotic take.

Remember you called Crosby underrated. You also called Malkin “merely a 2c”

I called Malkin an EXCEPTIONAL 2C.
You're right, I'm calling Hedman underrated because he didn't win the Norris, because he should be winning it every year.
It's not an idiotic take. Now you're resorting to name-calling, which I don't appreciate. I proved you wrong, and now you're unhappy about it.

Nov 28, 2020 at 8:27

#16

Caps fan idk why

Joined: Dec 2016

Posts: 8,468

Likes: 3,115

Quoting: HabsFan9

I called Malkin an EXCEPTIONAL 2C.
You're right, I'm calling Hedman underrated because he didn't win the Norris, because he should be winning it every year.
It's not an idiotic take. Now you're resorting to name-calling, which I don't appreciate. I proved you wrong, and now you're unhappy about it.

How half the people said Josi? You proved nothing. I used stats not cap friendly posters opinion. Facts > opinions. Lol Malkin is a 1c on 90% of NHL teams.

Nov 28, 2020 at 8:29

#17

Caps fan idk why

Joined: Dec 2016

Posts: 8,468

Likes: 3,115

Quoting: Bcarlo25

If you want to reduce it to that.

If you’re talking about playing hockey, it’s Crosby and Hedman, and its not close.

Reduce it to stats ? Malkin was on a 110 point pace this year? You said it’s not even close ?

Nov 28, 2020 at 8:34

#18

Joined: May 2018

Posts: 17,413

Likes: 5,649

Quoting: Capitalfail67

Reduce it to stats ? Malkin was on a 110 point pace this year? You said it’s not even close ?

Correct. Crosby is a better hockey player than Malkin. It isn’t close.

Nov 28, 2020 at 8:41

#19

Caps fan idk why

Joined: Dec 2016

Posts: 8,468

Likes: 3,115

Quoting: Bcarlo25

Correct. Crosby is a better hockey player than Malkin. It isn’t close.

Even though they literally have identical stats? I’m talking last 2 years not career? Crosby compared to .... Strome isn’t close but I guess if you want to be .... dramatic you can say it’s not even close. Down to individual awards it’s close. Oh well. Ignoring all stats I guess it’s not even close lol

Nov 28, 2020 at 8:45

#20

Joined: May 2018

Posts: 17,413

Likes: 5,649

Quoting: Capitalfail67

Even though they literally have identical stats? I’m talking last 2 years not career? Crosby compared to .... Strome isn’t close but I guess if you want to be .... dramatic you can say it’s not even close. Down to individual awards it’s close. Oh well. Ignoring all stats I guess it’s not even close lol

Well I’m talking about playing hockey. You’re talking about fantasy hockey.

Nov 28, 2020 at 8:53

#21

Caps fan idk why

Joined: Dec 2016

Posts: 8,468

Likes: 3,115

Quoting: Bcarlo25

Well I’m talking about playing hockey. You’re talking about fantasy hockey.

Points total are fantasy ? I understand..kind of what you mean. You’re going by the “eye test”. I can respect that but on paper they are close?

Nov 28, 2020 at 9:09

#22

Joined: May 2018

Posts: 17,413

Likes: 5,649

Quoting: Capitalfail67

Points total are fantasy ? I understand..kind of what you mean. You’re going by the “eye test”. I can respect that but on paper they are close?

Sure i guess. If you ask 1,000 coaches, players, executives if they could pick one, do you think any say Malkin? Unless its some Russia bias, i think the answer is literally zero.

HabsFan9 liked this.

Nov 28, 2020 at 9:30

#23

Caps fan idk why

Joined: Dec 2016

Posts: 8,468

Likes: 3,115

Quoting: Bcarlo25

Sure i guess. If you ask 1,000 coaches, players, executives if they could pick one, do you think any say Malkin? Unless its some Russia bias, i think the answer is literally zero.

Based off reputation or talent?

Nov 28, 2020 at 9:32

#24