You love to see Point moving down when he's getting better every year and is only 24

??

I think stone is too high, Seth Jones should be top five on rhd, but I mean Jones may be the most polarizing star on this site.

cant see it for tolvanen, tarasenko, spurgeon, pietrangelo

hmm

I think matthews will be in the top 5 with McDavid, Petey, Wright and Mackinnon

I also think Vasilevskiy wont be here and Adam Fox will be a lot higher

Theres probably more things, but I would have to take a deeper look at it

point was a hard one. i wanted to put him higher but i cant really push anyone lower imo. i based it on ceiling

thanks for the feedback. im worried fox will get backlash even though hes the best out of makar and hughes as a well rounded player wise

hes risky. i didnt want to get demolished lol

Pietrangelo at 35 over Heiskanen?

imo yes. heiskanen needs one more step in the right direction this year and then i can easily say that. piet is great right now and will be for more years

Has Hughes shown anything to say he will be better than Point in 5 years?

To be fair its also the type of game they play/encouraged to play. Hughes and makar were pretty much given the green light and are going to be 70 PT d men

In his defense did point show anything five years ago?

he'll be in his prime and Piet close to retirement age. And why does everybody like Makar more he only played one year and played with Mackinnon who is WAY better than any stars forward, plus Heiskanen is better defensively

Spurgeon a TOP5 RHD at 36?

I dig the guy but that's way optimistic.

Players like Tolvanen, Fiala, Gurianov and Shesterkin are interesting shouts but I think you're overselling on all of them.

Also I think it's a bit problematic that aside from Sanderson all TOP6 picks of 2020 draft plus Askarov are in this elite 60. This would make the 2020 draft class by far the best in NHL history, which frankly I don't believe is the case.

Point was a 3rd round pick. Hughes was 1st overall.

That's what I mean though, look at how point progressed, Hughes basically has five years to develop. He had a poor first season but so did Thornton, stamkos, lecavalier. There's some merit to ranking him high. Not saying it will happen but its not some out there opinion.

fair enough

this list is way off.

Not to mention it's way to early to do this.

Will Tarasenko even be playing in 5 years with his shoulder issues?

Draisaitl isn't a right winger he is a centre

Way too hard to predict 5 years from now. Some of the guys who will be the best in 5 years are still in high school LOL

Everybody wants to sleep on RobTom. You'll see.

Agreed. I don't know why, but I feel like Byfield is going to break a few Kings fans hearts...I just don't see him being a superstar. Should have a solid career, but to put him above Matthews (Who has put up insane goals per game numbers so far), Point (Who just keeps getting better and better), and Jack Eichel is a bit of a stretch. I mean, Barkov is only going to be 30 at that point as well...

I just feel like the list has a pretty significant recency bias. To assume that 3 picks from the 2020 draft will be the top 3 LWers as 23 year year olds is probably pretty off the mark. When you look at this years draft, yes, it was absolutely strong, but I don't see anyone other than Laffy jumping into the top 4 or 5 by then.

Matthews is 23 and somehow slid to the bottom too lol,

In 5 years Matthews, Mcdavid, point Eichel and McKinnon will still be top 5 centres in the league. This is assuming no other generational centre is drafted in the next couple of years.

Spelled Lucas wrong in Lucas Raymond, and he plays RW


Pietrangelo out

Clarke plays RD

Draisaitl plays C

WHY IS HAMILTON AHEAD OF MAKAR????

Sorokin is over Vasilevskiy for some reason

Juuse Saros isn't here???

Where is Holtz???


Jake Sanderson???


Dach and J. Hughes over Point?

WHERE IS AATU RATY AND DYLAN GUENTHER?


MATTHEWS IS SO LOW!!!