Edited Feb. 11, 2021 at 1:28 p.m.
Alright, in my opinion I ranked them as a tie, I need some input on this.
Scenario: The two players are dman of the same size, Option 2 is a offensive dman who likes to score and rushes the play with his size and skating abilities, and is 2x better than the other one in the offensive zone, Option 1 is more of a complete dman who likes to also rushes the puck but has more of the intent of making a play than to try to score like Option 2, option 1 is on the top unit PK and PP, which both of them are league leading because of him and his defensive play is 2x better than Option 2.
Option 1 has a better Slap shot, Wrist shot but Option 2 has better accuracy and a better quick release.
They both use checking to the MAX and they play on the same line.
BTW not in the NHL, in another league.
If you have any questions ask me.