Quoting: pharrow
I'm not pretending anything. I'm telling you facts. You put a 5'10" guy next to crosby, and much like they did Jake and Sheary, the other team will knock them down all over the ice and take away anyone for him to pass to. Period. End of story. We have seen this **** for 2 years now. So let me know when you are done with your make believe bs and ready to come back down to reality.
It's why they went out and over paid for a 6'1 guy to play next to him. Because they needed someone of some size and speed who can at least attempt to fight through it.
As I said before, I'd prefer to keep Rust. And Fiala is the wrong guy to play with Crosby ANYWAY. As in it doesn't F%%%%ing matter what the trade is. He has no business on Crosby's wing. Why that is so hard for you to accept is beyond me.
Call it a small line all you want, Fiala is heavier and stronger on his feet than Kapanen. Not to mention, more talented too. To me, having the more talented line, even if it means sacrificing some height is worth it.
Btw, why are you comparing Sheary to Fiala. Fiala is superior in every way other than he didn't play for the Pens before.
So while I get your point, and I don't disagree with it in a general sense, the options available don't really favour you as much as you'd like them. Height isn't the only version of size.
And while we're still here, I agree that you shouldn't be looking for a guy for Crosby when you have Kapanen. Not because of size, but instead because you already overpaid for him to play with Sid. However, I'm still team Fiala when it comes to which one of these two should be playing on the top line.