that is fair value BUT Anaheim already traded Andersen so idk if they want him back

That is not near enough, Freddy has no value in a Gibson trade. Sandin and a late first doesnt get you Gibsons skates

not even close, some people say gibson is near untouchable

My thought would be they flip him as well... Double down.

Fair.. Just thinking from a leafs persepctive he'd solidify their goaltending through-out there window of opportunity...

Thought, they would in turn flip freddy for another return.. perhaps Colorado has a look.

I agree, but at what point does he want out? Ducks aren't winning anytime soon....

What kind of return do you think it would take to get him? Leafs roster only.

Gibson isnt going to be traded, For the Ducks to even consider moving him they would have to be getting enough back to end their rebuild, he's signed to the best contract in the League for value they have no reason to move him unless its an absolutely insane overpay. he's young enough to still be elite by the time ANA will be competitive again

*is untouchable

Neither team makes this trade. Ducks will be looking for an overpay that the leafs don’t want to give up.

100%, and any deal with Gibson wouldnt make sense for the other team involved honestly, its the same reason Price was never traded. It doesnt make sense for ANA to move him for "Fair" value whatever that would be, they would need at least triple "fair" value to even think about it

If rutherford becomes the gm somehow... he'll probably accept

What would a gibson trade look like

My idea was (still working on it)

Liligren
Amirov
Kerfoot
and a 2021 1st
(may be an overpay but hey good young goalies with a good contract and term aint easy to find)

just curious as my prediction was Dubas may not extend Freddie and trade for one of Gibson or Kuemper

Still not close , it would be Nylander ++ or ANA doesnt consider.

And theres no way TOR should do that

well ducks are rebuilding ik your a ducks fan but if they offer them 2 1sts anderson sadin Liljegren thats a good offer imo if you can take one of those first and try to trade a goalie like goergiev in backup while anderson is playing out his contract thats a faster rebuild toronto will go all in soon with there cap they wont be able to resign anyone so i think they would do this

Ducks would want a top prospect. Like top top. A top player and a 1st rounder.

trade up with both of those 1st then defenitly could get you a top 3 and you still have the ducks pick, which if they get lucky might be high too

maybe i would think they would want a prospect tho

@cjacks1212

Quantity doesn’t get you quality

IMO goalies never get fair value in a trade. Look over the the last 20-30 years and see what goalies have been traded, and for what. It's actually hilarious.

yes it does 2 mid 1st round prospects 2 firsts rounds and a goalie get someone like georgiev and in a couple years he is a starter he is no gibson but

Wasnt asking, I was telling you. The only way TOR ever gets close to Gibson is Nylander +++

i dont know bout dat id perfer like nick roberts sadin 2 1st and anderson

What you prefer doesnt really matter

well ducks are rebuilding and nylander has played with mathews and taveres i think he is overrated