Quoting: JokiStan
I think you're underestimating how good Eichel is. Yeah, I'd argue he still would. With this deal your still shedding some cap and can sign UFA wingers. Secure a Franchise center with Zegras and worry about the rest later
See, I'm not a big believer in the "wave the magic wand" theory of asset management -- make some moves, and then just "sign [some] UFA wingers." Aside from the fact that the suggested transaction adds about $3 million to our cap (instead of "shedding it," as you say), signing two valuable UFA wingers would add yet another $10 million or more to our cap.
I'm perfectly happy with Max Comtois as our #1 LW. I don't have to worry if the guy we sign to replace him will turn into the next Jeff Skinner.
I'm perfectly happy with Max Jones as our #3 LW. I don't have to worry if the guy we sign to replace him for $5 million AAV will turn into the next Jason Zucker.
I'm perfectly happy with getting a reasonable return from trading Rickard Rakell and Sam Steel. I'd be satisfied if between them they brought a mid-round first and some extras.
And I'm REALLY happy at the thought of adding what could be a franchise player like Kirby Dach or Miro Heiskanen with our third-overall selection in this year's draft.
I'm not underestimating how good Jack Eichel is. On the contrary, I think he's so good that we can't afford him.