Ok, I think it's time to figure out who's the smartest "GM" on this site.


Criteria:

You cannot pick yourself.

Has to be someone who is creative but REASONABLE.

And maybe something else that I'm forgetting, not sure.

That andmei guy is pretty good.

Hmm quite a few on here actually, its hard to pick the "smartest" one without alienating others whose opinions I respect too.

I think the reason that the site works for good discussion is because different people have different expertise, so there is a system of validation to the reasonable posts.

...and that is why I am the smartest

I agree with Palhal more often than not despite being rival fan bases. I wouldnt say smartest, i would say he's a tier A GM. I'd put f50marco up there too, mikeyscav, all for different reason too

It's not Armstrong

I don't particularly have a "smartest". I think someone who leaves a description to why they did this and did that is a good GM, if you can explain then I respect you

The GM that brings the best and most free beer/food.

I've never seen one of Palhals teams, but his comments are very intelligent

I don't really read much outside of my own team's posts (Pens) but PalHal and F50Marco always have sound explanations behind any of their arguments, even if they are one's I disagree with.

I mean I've had my few share of arguments with Palhal and aha umm...

They don't always go over too smoothly.

I don't always agree with his analysis but he backs up any argument he is trying to make and, at least as far as I've seen, keeps it civil and polite.

Fair enough.

Thinking the guy(s) with the most posts, must be the loneliness GMS I appreciate guys/gals who have a worldly view of all teams. Not possible of course cause you can't see that many games.
Lots of guys present a good cases for many trades.....FMarco, Nick628, Shibbal, most folks present a case for their deals. Sometimes it's best to stop at two trades per team (for a while) instead of making a 10 player swap and thinking that is going to work for a team.
Today, I was talking to distant cousin, we live in the same town. HIs wife who studies genealogy and knows the family tree, believes we related to the great Bobby Orr. If confirmed, I will use my bloodlines to emphasize my point , however invalid.

nah, he couldn't even come up with a good name for starters.

Probably between mikeyscav, F50Marco, oh, and definitely Zbaddest............Ohhhhhhh sweet sarcasm!

Ditry Dangles

There is only one option. boltscharge17. Simply the best.

i think it's rangersandislesfan

Guys guys, I think that Booth guy was pretty good...till Mike Richards knocked him out cold