Okay, first of all your numbers don't check out
at all: when you add Eichel's hit to that roster you're $1,563,334 in the hole. Who were you planning on sending to the Barracuda to make up that difference?
Look, I realize that you're not alone in thinking that Eichel to San Jose would solve a our problems, but you - and everyone else who is hoping for this - are wrong.
As Juiceman has pointed out, we have a lot of really crappy contracts on the books. What he hasn't pointed out is the total: $41.5 million dollars tied up in five contracts, none of which expire until 24/25 - and two of them run until 26/27. If you throw in Eichel's $10 million cap hit, that's $51.5 million tied up in
six players, which leaves you with around $30 million for the rest of the team. You couldn't even make those numbers work for this season, what're you going to do about Hertl, Ferraro, and Knyzhov's new contracts next year? (If you're even thinking about saying "buy out some of the bad contracts" I encourage you to go play with the
buyout calculator - those contracts are
really not structured to be buyout friendly.)
Adding yet another huge contract to our already stupidly large collection of huge contracts is a bad, bad move. Adding one that's attached to a player who has a serious surgery ahead of him that may or may not affect his play going forward is an even worse move. Giving up what's mostly likely going to be a really goddamn high pick in a super deep draft with extremely good players available is just foolish.
And on top of all of that, Buffalo laughs you out of the room with that package. Simek, bless his heart, is not good. Labanc has had two back to back terrible seasons. Gambrell is a fourth line center. Kniazev has good numbers in juniors, but he's hardly a blue chip prospect. The Karlsson trade had significantly higher value in the players sent to Ottawa, not to mention better picks. This is just a big ol' NOPE all around.