If chariot is a 1st Holl is more than a 4th

Leafs aren't trading a 20 minute a night RHD for nothing.

He'd been healthy scratched several times this season. I see Leafs fans propose almost this exact trade like 5 times a day lmao

Chiarot ain't worth a 1st tho

if chariot is a 1st, Holl is a 1st+ because he wont get you a bunch of cross checking penalties or screen your goalie on every shot

the Leafs arnt moving Holl unless they can upgrade on D

Leafs have been wise, Exchanging Dmen for three spots, keeping everyone fresh and ready. Teams need seven or eight Dmen to get through a season. Certainly the Leafs aren't trading an NHL Dmen without getting a better one back.
You've (and me) have reading these foolish Leafs trades trading Holl/Dermot/Liljegren. Holl for instance plays 20 minutes a night, (that's makes him top 4 RHD) is minute PK guy. Leafs are 8th in PK and 2nd in GAA this year. Holl is a 2m great value this year and next.

The healthy scratches were mainly to rotate Sandin, Liljegren, Dermott and Holl in 3 spots. Holl did struggle a bit early in the season and also was under weight making people speculate that he has been not well.

Holl's not an allstar but also isn't a dog like some make him out to be.

All reasonable enough. I'd figured if he's a guy they're willing to rotate in that group that the Leafs would try to shed his salary out of the bunch in order to chase a top-6 F at the TDL, while also maybe looking into a cheap, somewhat equivalent option at D. But y'all watch the Leafs more than I do so I'll assume it fair that he isn't being moved right now

I think that would be the thing that I have a different perspective on than you...I think Dubas would move Holl + ?? for a somewhat better option at D. If not then I think the savings to trade a player only making $2 MIL and fits in with the guys in the locker room for a player that could adversely affect the fantastic team chemistry for only half a MIL or so is too big a risk to simply stay the same skill/talent-wise.