I'd rather have Eichel.

SOOOOO MUCH!!!!

In my opinion, they're all excessive.
-Maybe take Deni out of the Panthers one
-Byram, when healthy, has already shown that he can be as good as Chychrun.
-Mayyyybe on the Edmonton one.
-Take Faber out of the LA one, but Kings fans likely won't be pleased.
-Change one of the 1sts to a 2nd in the Rangers one and it's a little closer.
-Penguins one seems a bit weird...aside from the 2 firsts you've got a bunch of question marks coming over.
-Leafs isn't bad, but I'd question their actual desire to add Chychrun. Taking on salary for a 5th left handed dman doesn't seem ideal (Though he's absolutely an upgrade). Basically means there's zero chance of re-signing Campbell though.
-That Caps one is excessive. Almost equates to moving 5 1st round picks. They'd be a good team to target for Chychrun, but that's a boatload to give up.

Chych isn't exactly having a lights out season, not sure he's worth THIS much.

I agree, most of these packages are way to much to give up for Chychrun

they wont even demand that much from the Avs, they have 0 comparable to even begin to ask for that package or similar packages from almost the majority of the teams here.
Chychrun is a very good dman but he is not some elite 2way dman god, his underlying numbers and impacts have slipped recently.

It would shock a lot of people that Sam Girards numbers are very very simliar to his. Would teams by paying those prices for Girard?

Just to add to this:

Definitely an upgrade? I'm not convinced. His goal scoring rate is higher but otherwise Girard appears to be the more well rounded defenseman pic.twitter.com/bp6tcdenrQ

— AJ MacReady (@QuotelessJones) January 31, 2022

Kings aren’t trading faber

exactly my point. Talented Dmen with their strengths and flaws, they arent perfect. So why does 1 get the rep of being a franchise number 1 Dman? If Girard for 3 inches taller people would talk completely different than him despite playing the same way

Turcotte and the 2022 first plus a prospect like Strand or Moverare is about as high as I would go for Chychrun, considering that he's having the worst season in his career.

Inasmuch as Arizona has about 8 NHL-quality players (forwards AND defensemen put together) under contract for next season, I think this might be one of the few cases where one team might be willing to exchange quality for quantity. Guys like Alex Iafallo and Sean Walker might be better as a pair than Turcotte.

Thanks for not appreciating the cap of other teams. IMO all teams say no.

These are all so massive packages! Chychrun has had one good season, his value shouldn't be even half of what people think it is.

Some of these returns are closer to McDavid's value than Chychrun's

ACGM’s crack me up. “That’s what they will ask”. No they won’t. They have to work with other GM’s and to be taken seriously you don’t make a hair brained demands or outlandish proposals. Literally every single one of these proposals is a ridiculous. This is not a well thought out or remotely realistic ACGM.