Forsberg doesn't need convincing he said he would stay. Isles decline

The Columbus Anyteams pass.

Nothing about Nashville moving Jeannot is realistic. He is someone who defines their teams new identity

Sorry ,despite your thought, not one trade any non Leaf team would make. The worse.....Isles giving up a two good assets for a UFA

The obsession with jeannot is fascinating and i always wonder if people realise hes only a year younger than nylander and couldnt even touch nylanders rookie year despite being much older

Ducks aren’t giving up a second for Muzzin 😂

We’re rebuilding not competing

Ahhh the old sign-a-ufa-then-immediately-trade-him move

No team is taking a 3rd and a 4th to eat Mrazek.

It’s more the physical side of things that people love about Jeannot. Nylander is the superior scorer/playmaker. Jeannot is the bigger and much more physical player. Nylander has 107 hits over 7 seasons. Jeannot has 318 in just 1 season. He’s willing to get into the dirty places and throw his body around and he still contributes on the scoreboard which is pretty rare for his style of player. Folingo, b. Tkachuk, and t. Wilson are the only players within 100 hits of him that also have 40+ points

Ah yes, love to be obsessed with a stat that counters cant even agree on how to track. Hits is the most useless counting number there is

Physical play can be treasured by certain teams… Nashville is one of them. You can argue about best way of tracking it but it’s undeniable Jeannot is much more physical than nylander.

And he's not nearly as good at the rest of hockey, so it doesn't matter if he's more physical. Ristolainen is much more physical than rielly, should the leafs make that trade?

Giving up a 2nd is nowhere near a steal for Anaheim — it legit makes no sense

Ristolainen also has a terrible contract. I don’t think anyone should trade for him. I think a more apt comparison would be a younger But less proven tom wilson. Jeannots numbers this year are on par with Wilson when he was 24. Will it go beyond this year? Who knows.

Not sure what the leafs needs are or how much their leadership/gm want to up their physical game.

In a vacuum, this trade proposal is bad value to the leafs. Nylander is the better player in all facets of the game outside of physicality.

It’s also not the direction Nashville wishes to take because they have purposely been going for a more physical style of play and nylander doesn’t fit that.