Joined: May 2018
Posts: 9,443
Likes: 4,149
Leafs are paying too much in here.
They give up -
1. 2023 1st rd pick (TOR)
2. Nicholas Robertson
3. 2024 2nd rd pick (TOR)
4. Roni Hirvonen
5. 2022 3rd round pick (WPG).
6. Justin Holl
7. Alex Kerfoot
8. Nick Abruzzese
9. Petr Mrazek
for
William Karlsson, Robin Lehner, 2022 5th rd pick (TOR)
Karlsson is borderline cap dump at this point (although I like him a lot). So call him even or of little value. I like Lehner and he would be a decent solution for the Leafs and a 5th rounder.
None of that equals what we give up. Mrazek is the only negative asset in there. Let's say him and Kerfoot cancel each other out. You give a 1st, 2nd, 3rd, A- Prospect in Robertson, 2 B prospects, Holl who is worth 3rd-5th round pick. So lets say he cancels out the 5th.
I am not giving a 1st, 2nd, 3rd, A- Prospect in Robertson, 2 B prospects for Lehner and Karlsson. Goalies don't have a crazy trade value and Karlsson isn't fully living up to his cap.
I like the creativity though but this will need some rework (at least from the Leafs perspective)