No

I think it's a pretty fair deal. While I think you could get better prospects from another team, the firsts make up for it.

Miller isn't worth that, especially not to the leafs.

Friendly reminder that deadline trade packages tend to be more valuable than off season deals, so you missed your shot to get a package anywhere near that from anyone and honestly you may as well wait until the deadline as you'll only lose about 10-20% of his value despite using 60-75% of the season up

too much for a rental price, even if he sign an extension you aren't getting 4 1sts. Niemela and a 1st is a decent base

Would it be fair if the 2023 pick was changed to their 3rd?

1 season of a player isn't worth this kind of return. You are probably looking at a 1st and a good prospect as a base with small things thrown in to make cap work or deal with other concerns.

No, again rental prices are not that high. You are probably looking at a similar but slightly better return than Fiala

I think Miller might be staying if they move Garland instead. The UFA market will pretty much show Miller what he could be in for, if the numbers are lower than he expects perhaps he resigns in Vancouver at an affordable amount for them which is probably 8.5 at the most.

One year of miller wouldnt be worth that if he was 25 let alone almost 30

The extra 1st rounder breaks the deal.

I think we should stop with Miller -> Toronto trades…

So you think Miller is worth a 1st rd pick and prospect MORE than Fiala who was an RFA?

Leafs laugh at that

VAN and TOR don't make good trade partners for a Miller trade.