Seems pretty unlikely that Carolina does that

Necas has much more value than Puljujarvi

Well he is not a first round pick add. So what a 3rd to a 2nd?
Is that much more?

My original trade was Barrie and JP for Necas. Which I am ok with.

So after being swept by the Avs in the playoffs and seeing Keith retire, your solution is to spend more on offense, less on defense, and practically nothing in goal...?

What is the difference in lineup with forwards. Lost JP and added Necas
Got a better goalie. In fact both goalies are better than Smith and Koskinen
And added our future number 2 D.

Whats the problem. We should have played Skinner the whole playoffs. Husso is gone and Keumper I am not signing for 5 years.

Canes wouldn’t be good with that tho.

Better goalie? Comrie as 28 career games. He was a fine backup last year but 19 games vs usually worse teams does not make him a "better goalie"

How about Barrie and JP for Necas?

Statistically he is better by far than Kuemper. Kuemper was below average in the playoffs in dangerous chances.
Skinner is ready and the 2 of them can grow together. I dont want to give what Kuemper is going to get.
And like goalie experts say, Comrie is just coming into his own.

Comrie on a bad team was .920
Kuemper on the best team with the leagues best Defenseman .921

Why is Necas worth more than Puljujarvi? He certainly doesn't perform better.

Necas v Puljujarvi

Necas was a drag on his team while Puljujarvi elevated everyone he played with. Carolina would have to chip in something else or this is a clear loss for Edmonton.

You have to consider the sample size

You’re comparing 19 games to 57

I got a plan if we get rid of Barrie. Sign Manson

19 games... He played entirely as a backup. So the only time he ever saw the net was in back to backs or bottom feeders

Yup and last year Kuemper played appr 60 games. Every year before that he played approx under 30.

Just like Kuemper until last year right?
Yah just like. Oh besides 1 other year.

What are you talking about? Kuemper was the starting goalie in Arizona every season.

Sorry I was looking at the stats.

2015-16 Minnesota Wild NHL 21 0 2 1055 43 2 2 2.43 6 7 5 464 0.915 - - -
2016-17 Minnesota Wild NHL 18 1 4 1058 55 0 0 3.13 8 5 3 507 0.902 - - -
2017-18 Los Angeles Kings NHL 19 1 0 999 35 0 3 2.10 10 1 3 481 0.932 - - -
2017-18 Arizona Coyotes NHL 10 0 0 597 32 0 1 3.22 2 6 2 285 0.899 - - -
2018-19 Arizona Coyotes NHL 55 2 14 3251 126 0 5 2.33 27 20 8 1551 0.925 - - -
2019-20 Arizona Coyotes NHL 29 0 6 1753 65 0 2 2.22 16 11 2 838 0.928 9 0 0
2019-20 Tucson Roadrunners AHL 1 0 0 59 2 2 0 2.05 0 1 0 26 0.929
2020-21 Arizona Coyotes NHL 27 0 4 1547 66 0 2 2.56 10 11 3 644 0.907 - - -
2021-22 Colorado Avalanche NHL 57 0 2 3259 138 0 5 2.54 37 12 4 1616 0.921 16 1 2
2021-22p Colorado Avalanche NHL 16 1 2 887 38 0 1 2.57 10 3 1 348 0.902

%%gp once and 57 games played once

His lower games played in the last previous 2 seasons were because of injuries but he was 100% the starter when healthy. But hey if you want to run a waiver wire goalie as your starter I have super exited as a Flames fan

No thanks. Wouldn’t include Necas in a trade for either of them. Could send you picks if there was actual interest from canes

Maybe he's just following Sakic's example?

Ok than keep the better player - notice it’s never canes posts that have Necas for Pulj swaps, always oilers ones.

Puljujärvi stats

Here are some more of his underlying numbers, and how they rank among the aforementioned 171 players:

CF/60 – 1st
CA/60 – 29th
SCF/60 – 23rd
SCA/60 – 128th
GF/60 – 55th
GA/60 – 9th
xGF/60 – 5th
xGA/60 – 69th
OR
https://twitter.com/zjlaing/status/1524477349240004610?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1524477349240004610%7Ctwgr%5E%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.redditmedia.com%2Fmediaembed%2Funmvnc%3Fresponsive%3Dtrueis_nightmode%3Dfalse
OR
https://www.facebook.com/OilersNation/photos/a.1290639507657089/5152399664814368

Lol OKAY, no problem.

Gladly.