I voted fair deal as I think this makes sense for both teams.

FLA knew that they were not able to keep both Huberdeau and Weegar around, so turning both of them into a 24 year old power forward for the next 8 years is a great investment from them in the long run.

CGY doesn't have to settle on retooling after losing two of their core players, which is instantly a W for them. But they also take a huge gamble here, as both of these guys they've taken are veterans close to their 30s, and they both need to get re-signed, which is bound to get really expensive. Luckily for them both Monahan and Lucic have expiring contracts this year so keeping both of them is in theory very possible, assuming they're not pulling a Gaudreau and walking away from more money than they'd get by staying in Calgary.

Florida's win is that they get the risk free option, CGY could turn out getting more value out of this but they're taking a much bigger gamble here.

Only a W for the Flames if they extend Huberdeau. Massive W if they can keep both him and Weegar

Trade confirmed: Calgary Flames - Florida Panthers

I like this way of thinking. Also, I wonder if Huby’s performance in the playoffs this year played a role in Bill Zito being willing to give him up in this trade.

All jokes aside, this trade actually makes sense from a Florida standpoint because it was highly unlikely that they could keep Huberdeau and Weegar after next season, and they receive an elite young power forward locked up on an 8 year deal to play beside Barkov for them. Giving up another 1st and solid prospect isn't the most logical move though.

Calgary of course gets Huberdeau to hopefully try to pick up where Gaudreau left off, and Weegar to solidify their top 4 D core. Plus a first round pick and great prospect in Schwindt creates a perfect return for the flames. Now only time will tell who wins this trade in the long run once we see what's left of Huberdeau and Weegar for 23-24 for Calgary.

Could they not offer them extensions thus year and if they don't accept - trade at deadline?

Need to note that Calgary gets two Canadian players ... Coincidence? I think not!

This one will need a year to know who won, depends on if they re-signs. Now who gets traded to go under the cap? Hörnqvist with prospects to no man's land?

All jokes aside, this trade actually makes sense from a Florida standpoint because it was highly unlikely that they could keep Huberdeau and Weegar after next season, and they receive an elite young power forward locked up on an 8 year deal to play beside Barkov for them. Giving up another 1st and solid prospect isn't the most logical move though.

Calgary of course gets Huberdeau to hopefully try to pick up where Gaudreau left off, and Weegar to solidify their top 4 D core. Plus a first round pick and great prospect in Schwindt creates a perfect return for the flames. Now only time will tell who wins this trade in the long run once we see what's left of Huberdeau and Weegar for 23-24 for Calgary.

Obviously, CGY crushed it, but I really like this move by FLA. They're in better position to win in the playoffs now then they were yesterday. By far. Lundell and Reinhart will pick up the offensive slack in Huberdeau's absence. Both teams get big W's here.

This could very well be the blockbuster of the decade, I like this a lot for Calgary
**BUT** Calgary needs to sit down right now and get an extension done on both of them (or Atleast Huberdeau) for any future success, and Calgary can absolutely throw the book at him, they have the money.
I don’t get it for Florida, I like Tkachuk yes, but 9.5M? It’s a bit steep

(Now wait for this post to blow up really badly in my face)