Joined: Sep. 2020
Posts: 3,246
Likes: 1,859
Completely forgot about the season thread, so I'm going to restate what I posted recently on an ACGM re: replacing Brown going forward. Between Sheary, MoJo (who a lot of people owe MacLellan an apology about), Protas, Eller, Snively, McMichael, Milano, and Hathaway we have plenty of guys who can play the wing, get some special teams minutes, and chip in around 15/20/35. Because of health issues, I'm only expecting slightly better from Oshie, Wilson, and Backstrom. That leaves only Ovi, Kuzy, Strome, and Mantha as guys I am very confident will crack 50 points, and only really Ovi and Kuzy will get close to a point per game. What they are really missing is another bona-fide top 6 player who can actually drive play and scoring themselves, rather than just be a complimentary piece.
Going after Domi, JVR, Drouin, Dadonov, etc. will just put them right back where they were (as well as take away even more chances for McMichael and Snively to get minutes). It might raise the floor a bit given that with playing the young guys there is a much greater chance that they flame out, but it certainly doesn't raise our ceiling at all. Garland or Anderson would be a step above as direct Brown replacements and are definitively top-6 guys, but like Brown, Mantha, and Strome are much better suited serving a secondary role next to other elite players rather than driving a line themself.
Even though it wold probably cost a 1st and McMichael or Lapierre, my top choices for a Brown replacement would be Meier, Kane, Tarasenko, Bratt, Konecny, Schmaltz, PLD, Scheifle, and Pastrnak. Obviously not all those guys will be available but they all theoretically could be if their respective teams fall way out of the playoff race. Of those Meier is IMO the perfect fit -- a team that is clearly awful and desperately needs to start accumulating future assets, coming off of a ppg season, has consistently controlled possession throughout his career, only 26, and a high QO (that the caps could fit in) could bring the price down a la DeBrincat, only making 6m this year so could fit in relatively easily under the cap.