Joined: Aug. 2017
Posts: 8,440
Likes: 6,060
Seems like too much for Horvat imo. Take out either the 2nd or the prospect
TDL rental Cs:
Copp = Morgan Barron + 1st + 2nd (this is the best case scenario imo, where you get two picks and a prospect and get lucky with a conditional pick upgrading because the team makes a deep playoff run)
Giroux = Tippett + 1st + 3rd (Giroux is significantly better than Horvat but the NMC complicated things and lowered the return, im not sure how useful this is as a comp)
Pageau = 1st + 2nd (this is roughly what I think he would get, maybe swap the 2nd for a prospect instead of the pick. Pageau in 2020 is similar in value to Horvat now)
Hayes = Lemieux + 1st (This is the lower end of the trade return imo. Hayes was significantly better in 18-19 than Horvat is now but for whatever reason only got a 1st + young bottom 6 roster player)
Stastny = Foley + 1st (Stastny in 17-18 was also better than Horvat is now imo. This return is also on the lower end of a prospect + 1st)