we miss leo k
Joined: Feb. 2018
Posts: 5,973
Likes: 5,107
i gotta lot of questions about these values!!
-I think Poehling for Bortuzzo works in a vacuum, value-wise, but I don't know who St. Louis brings up to play RD3 if they trade Bortuzzo - which makes him more valuable to them than another 4C like Poehling.
-I don't see anything in this that makes sense for Toronto - you're giving them a mild upgrade from Gaudette to Archibald, I guess, and Ruhwedel is an affordable depth D, but I think Kerfoot to McGinn is a major downgrade for them - both in terms of the player, and in terms of term - I don't think they want to save that $750K enough to sign on for 2 more years of McGinn.
-Wow! This is terrible for Vancouver - Petry probably doesn't waive to go back into Canada, first off, but even then I don't see the value here. Garland is a strong middle-6 wing, Hoglander is already a solid middle-6er at 21 with more upside than Kapanen, and Vancouver doesn't need to move the last year of Ferland's LTIR contract. I would also question the wisdom of Vancouver trading youth for veterans when their team has looked a little less than playoff-ready so far this year.
-Nothing here for CBJ to make the deal. Blueger is a bottom-6 guy, Maniscalco is playing in the ECHL, and a 5th isn't enough for a guy who's probably their 2nd-best Dman currently. If they want to sell him off in his UFA year, they could easily top the Ben Chiarot package from last year (1st/3rd/solid prospect) - maybe even more based on his age and their ability to retain him down to $1.4M.
-Now this trade is an extreme tilt back the other way - why would you give up Dumo *and* a decent prospect in Hallander to get back a 7th D like Beaulieu? If you need to move Dumoulin's cap, I'm sure you can find a taker for his deal - at the very least, the team you've built right here has the cap space where you could fully retain him down and send him to some team at $2.05M and get *something* back, instead of sacrificing a prospect to get back a warm body.
-I'm not sure how I feel on this one - I don't think it makes sense to trade Legare for a guy that you're just going to stick on the 4th line; but I don't think there's enough here for Chicago to retain $2.5M this year and next. Both sides probably decline this one.