All things considered, who gets the higher AAV if they both sign long-term?

J
B
I
T
B
P
I
T
N
H
L

I think DeBrincat by 500k (8.5 vs 9M)

I genuinely think Bratt will take a small discount with New Jersey, while I don't see Debrincat doing the same thing.

I could be wrong, but weren't there rumours last year about Debrincat looking for 10.5+ on his next deal?

My guess is DeBrincat. He likely has a higher perceived value than Bratt (multiple 40 goal seasons, former 1st round pick [just kidding he wasn't], more of a track record), plus he's had more exposure from playing in Chicago with Kane along with the big trade to Ottawa, whereas Bratt has gotten much less coverage in New Jersey, despite being just as good the past couple seasons.

Debrincat wasn't a first round pick

Whoops, you're right. I had it in my head that he was taken late in the 1st round.