Sharks decline 50% retention on Karlsson isn't happening. Other than that value isn't bad. SJ also said Hertl is untouchable but if you take out the retention this might be enough to get them to change their minds about that.

Neither Toronto nor New York does this

Toronto would do it in a heartbeat. Reilly isn’t worth 7.5 mill

Umm no they would not.

I wouldn't bet on it and yes he is worth 7.5 mil.

Two first round picks for Reilly?
Isles pass

I mean that Toronto wouldn’t trade nylander, beau, and four first round picks for hertl and karlsson

Everyone passes except San Jose who gets a bazillion first round picks and a point a game player.

Four (shouldnt be high) 1sts and a floater, for 2 better players and eating 50% of the contract, Isles are getting shafted

Floater eh? I suggest maybe you watch some games this year. I forgot that all Leaf players and prospects suck.

Odd that the floater has more points, makes less and is younger though.🤔 To be fair I did include the Islanders in my comment so I am not sure what you are going on about and if you agree (at least partly), why make the trade up in the first place?

Are you really making an argument for Nylander>Hertl? says enough for me lol

Brush up on those reading skills my boy. I am disputing the floater and pointing out how he is not by comparing him with your boy. You won't get points like that if you are a floater. I did mention that If you find the word "better" of combination of words."better than" please let me know.

Was anything I said wrong? Hmm let me check...no, no it wasn't.

I did say you should watch a few games before you go on with your "expertise". Some of the Leaf haters don't have a clue but talk like they do, i am not necessarily lumping you in with this, but some of the stupidity is mind blowing and has zero basis in fact...but heh all the cool kids take laughble shots at the Leafs because...well I guess they are cool?

Ive watched them enough Nylander is an overpaid floater, 0 play drive, 0 forecheck, he hopes and prays someone finds him at the top of the circle

Lol apparently you haven't watched this year my friend, but whatever we'll keep him.

Hehe overpaid for a point a game player...

Its okay if you dont understand value in players and their contracts but you dont need to bring your lack of knowledge onto my post

Ummm ok you got me. 6.9 for a point a game player, yeah brutal value there man. One of us has no clue and well... it ain't me. This is getting kind of sad now because you have nothing so I am out of here, but if you're bored look at some comparable and not just the ones who took discounts to stay with their team.

Have fun crowing about how you beat me man, you are the best.🤣

It's OK...........he probably see's Wheeler as worth his 8M and Dillon / Demelo as $6M dmen.

People love to bust on Nylander, but the guy is a hell of a hockey player. His defensive zone coverage still needs some work, but he's made some pretty big strides. He's out killing penalties at times, and quite often out protecting a lead when the goaltender is out. I'd rather have him on my team than Ehlers or Dubois. H'll never be a big hitter, but I can live with that.

Rather have Nylander than Dubois? You just a hater dont talk to my about value peasnent

Reilly
Nylander
Out

McDavid
Nurse
1st Rd pick
In

I wouldn't trade those Leafs but that's a more realistic deal I think..