Quoting: Gronk9911
For a 37 point player who’s-28………..I don’t necessarily like the trade myself but the 2nd & 4th are well within the range, prospect is probably alright too considering you have NO defence.
But what more do you really expect?
Seriously, at least counter that because the only thing I find strange about that proposal is your demands.
Firstly he's still on his ELC which is currently under league minimum heading into next season and he is a 20 goal scorer on the leagues worst team.....
We have an abundance of young D coming through who are pencilled in to get gametime next season and the proposed defensemen coming back is also born the same year as Raddysh (a player you think is 28)
His value at the TDL to a team competing wanting to add to their forward pack with limited cap space will likely pay a 1st at the very minimum and quite possibly more when you consider what some of the contending teams have paid recently.
One question I would ask is "why would we do the oilers any favours?"
The offer doesn't even include a pick this year.... Why not just wait until TDL anyway?
The proposed player also plays the one position we don't need and the draft picks are down the line.
How can you be so perplexed about that proposal being rejected?
Im not saying he will get Jeannot or Hagel Return but he should get a much better return than whats proposed here. The fact multiple ACGM have proposed moves wanting him suggests he's been noticed around the league by fans at the very least.
Btw, you've asked to counter and then said my demands are strange....